Lipworth B J, Hall I P, Aziz I, Tan K S, Wheatley A
Department of Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, University of Dundee, Dundee DD1 9SY, Scotland, U.K.
Clin Sci (Lond). 1999 Mar;96(3):253-9.
The aim of the present study was to investigate bronchoprotective sensitivity in patients receiving regular treatment with short- and long-acting beta2-agonists and to evaluate any possible association with genetic polymorphism. Thirty-eight patients with stable mild to moderate asthma and receiving inhaled corticosteroids were randomized in a parallel group, double-blind, double-dummy fashion to receive 2 weeks of treatment with either formoterol (12 microg once daily, 6 microg twice daily or 24 microg twice daily) or terbutaline (500 microg four times daily). Bronchoprotection against methacholine challenge (as a provocative dose to produce a 20% fall in forced expiratory volume in 1.0 s: PD20) was measured at baseline (unprotected) after an initial 1 week run-in without beta2-agonist, and at 1 h after the first and last doses of each treatment. The PD20 values were log-transformed and calculated as change from baseline. Percentage desensitization of log PD20 for first- versus last-dose bronchoprotection was calculated and analysed according to effects of treatment and beta2-adrenoceptor polymorphism at codon 16 or 27. The mean degree of desensitization for bronchoprotection was comparable with all four treatments and there were no significant differences in absolute PD20 values after 2 weeks of chronic dosing. The PD20 values were (as microg of methacholine, geometric means+/-S. E.M.): formoterol, 12 microg once daily, 99+/-42 microg; formoterol, 6 microg twice daily, 107+/-44 microg; formoterol, 24 microg twice daily, 108+/-45 microg; terbutaline, 500 microg four times daily, 88+/-37 microg. All patients receiving formoterol, 24 microg twice daily, exhibited a loss of protection greater than 30% which was unrelated to polymorphism at codon 16 or 27. For codon 16, the use of lower doses of formoterol (12 microg once daily or 6 microg twice daily) showed wider variability in the propensity for protection loss in patients who were heterozygous, in contrast to a more uniform protection loss seen with homozygous glycine patients. The amount of protection loss was not significantly related to polymorphism at codon 16 or 27, expressed as values (mean+/-S.E.M.) for percentage desensitization according to each genotype (pooled treatments): Gly-16, 66+/-11%; Het-16, 53+/-8%; Arg-16, 69+/-18%; Glu-27, 68+/-12%; Het-27, 58+/-8%; Gln-27, 52+/-12%. The results of this preliminary study showed that bronchoprotective desensitization occurred readily in response to short- or long-acting beta2-agonist exposure irrespective of beta2-adrenoceptor polymorphism at codon 16 or 27. Further studies with larger patient numbers are required to further evaluate the effects of polymorphisms with lower doses of regular formoterol.
本研究的目的是调查接受短效和长效β2受体激动剂常规治疗的患者的支气管保护敏感性,并评估其与基因多态性的任何可能关联。38例病情稳定的轻度至中度哮喘患者,正在接受吸入性糖皮质激素治疗,他们被随机分为平行组,采用双盲、双模拟方式,接受为期2周的福莫特罗(每日1次,每次12微克;或每日2次,每次6微克;或每日2次,每次24微克)或特布他林(每日4次,每次500微克)治疗。在初始1周的导入期(不使用β2受体激动剂)后,于基线(未受保护状态)以及每种治疗的首次和末次给药后1小时,测量对乙酰甲胆碱激发试验的支气管保护作用(以引起1秒用力呼气量下降20%的激发剂量:PD20表示)。将PD20值进行对数转换,并计算相对于基线的变化。根据治疗效果以及第16或27密码子处的β2肾上腺素能受体多态性,计算并分析首次与末次给药支气管保护的对数PD20的脱敏百分比。所有四种治疗的支气管保护脱敏平均程度相当,慢性给药2周后绝对PD20值无显著差异。PD20值(以乙酰甲胆碱微克数表示,几何平均数±标准误)分别为:福莫特罗,每日1次,每次12微克,99±42微克;福莫特罗,每日2次,每次6微克,107±44微克;福莫特罗,每日2次,每次24微克,108±45微克;特布他林,每日4次,每次500微克,88±37微克。所有接受每日2次、每次24微克福莫特罗治疗的患者,其保护作用丧失均大于30%,这与第16或27密码子处的多态性无关。对于第16密码子,使用较低剂量福莫特罗(每日一次,每次12微克或每日2次,每次6微克)时,杂合子患者保护作用丧失的倾向变异性更大,而纯合甘氨酸患者的保护作用丧失则更为一致。保护作用丧失的程度与第16或27密码子处的多态性无显著相关性,以每种基因型(合并治疗)的脱敏百分比(平均值±标准误)表示分别为:Gly-16,66±11%;Het-16,53±8%;Arg-16,69±18%;Glu-27,68±12%;Het-27,58±8%;Gln-27,52±12%。这项初步研究的结果表明,无论第16或27密码子处的β2肾上腺素能受体多态性如何,短期或长期暴露于β2受体激动剂后,支气管保护脱敏均容易发生。需要进行更大规模患者的进一步研究,以进一步评估较低剂量常规福莫特罗多态性的影响。