Yaşar Işcan M, Steyn M
Department of Anatomy, University of Pretoria, South Africa.
Int J Legal Med. 1999;112(2):91-7. doi: 10.1007/s004140050208.
A vital aspect of skeletal analysis is the determination of population affinity of an unknown individual. The aim of this paper is to develop discriminant function formulae to determine race from craniometric dimensions of South African blacks and whites. Skeletons used in this study came from the Universities of the Witwatersrand and Pretoria. The sample is composed of 53 white males and 53 white females and 45 black males and 45 black females. Using 13 standard cranial and 4 mandibular dimensions, average accuracies of 98% were obtained from the crania, which were much more discriminatory than the mandibles (74% males, 87% females). When a "leave-one-out classification" technique was applied to the sample to measure accuracy of multivariate classification, this accuracy was about the same as obtained from the multivariate function. A posterior probability of 0.80 or more was found in as much as 96% of the sample. Stepwise discriminant function formulae for incomplete remains (vault and face) were also derived. Prediction accuracy was considerably lower when North American based formulae were tested on the South Africans, indicating significant craniometric differences between these populations.
骨骼分析的一个重要方面是确定未知个体所属的人群。本文的目的是开发判别函数公式,以便根据南非黑人和白人的颅骨测量尺寸来确定种族。本研究中使用的骨骼来自威特沃特斯兰德大学和比勒陀利亚大学。样本包括53名白人男性、53名白人女性、45名黑人男性和45名黑人女性。利用13个标准颅骨尺寸和4个下颌骨尺寸,从颅骨得出的平均准确率为98%,其区分能力比下颌骨(男性74%,女性87%)强得多。当对样本应用“留一法分类”技术来测量多变量分类的准确率时,该准确率与从多变量函数得出的结果大致相同。在多达96%的样本中发现后验概率为0.80或更高。还推导了不完整遗骸(颅顶和面部)的逐步判别函数公式。当基于北美的公式在南非人身上进行测试时,预测准确率要低得多,这表明这些人群之间存在显著的颅骨测量差异。