Yelnik A, Albert T, Bonan I, Laffont I
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Department, GH Lariboisière-F. Widal, Paris, France.
Stroke. 1999 Mar;30(3):580-5. doi: 10.1161/01.str.30.3.580.
The aim of this study was to assess the role of knee and ankle extensor overactivity in the hemiplegic gait observed in stroke victims and to propose a clinical guide for selecting patients before treatment of a supposed disabling spasticity.
A standardized physical examination procedure was performed in 135 consecutive stroke patients. All patients were able to walk without human assistance. The period after stroke ranged from 3 to 24 months (mean, 11.5+/-7.25 months). Spasticity was evaluated with the stroke victim in sitting position and during walking. Overactivity of the quadriceps was considered disabling when inducing inability to flex the knee during the swing phase despite adequate control of knee flexion in sitting and standing positions; overactivity of the triceps surae was considered to be disabling when heel strike was not possible despite good control of the ankle flexion in sitting position; triceps retraction was also considered.
Disabling overactivity was observed in 56 (41.5%) patients: 11 times for the quadriceps femoris, 21 times for the triceps surae, and 21 times for both muscles. It was considered to be the main disorder impairing gait among only 16 (12%) patients: 9 for the quadriceps alone, 3 for the triceps alone, and 4 for both. Sitting spasticity of the lower limb was not predictive of disabling overactivity during walking.
Extensor muscle overactivity is one of the components of gait disorders in stroke patients. The difficulty in assessing spasticity and its real causal effect in gait disturbances are discussed. A clinical guide is proposed.
本研究旨在评估膝部和踝部伸肌过度活动在中风患者偏瘫步态中的作用,并为在假定的致残性痉挛治疗前选择患者提出临床指南。
对135例连续的中风患者进行标准化体格检查程序。所有患者均能在无人协助下行走。中风后时间为3至24个月(平均11.5±7.25个月)。在患者坐位和行走时评估痉挛情况。尽管在坐位和站立位时膝关节屈曲得到充分控制,但在摆动期导致无法屈曲膝关节时,股四头肌过度活动被认为是致残性的;尽管在坐位时踝关节屈曲得到良好控制,但无法实现足跟触地时,腓肠肌三头肌过度活动被认为是致残性的;还考虑了三头肌回缩情况。
56例(41.5%)患者出现致残性过度活动:股四头肌11次,腓肠肌三头肌21次,两者均出现21次。仅在16例(12%)患者中,它被认为是损害步态的主要障碍:仅股四头肌9例,仅腓肠肌三头肌3例,两者均有4例。下肢坐位痉挛不能预测行走时的致残性过度活动。
伸肌过度活动是中风患者步态障碍的组成部分之一。讨论了评估痉挛及其在步态障碍中真正因果效应的困难。提出了临床指南。