Postoperative flow cytometry crossmatch in living donor liver transplantation: clinical significance of humoral immunity in acute rejection.

BACKGROUND

The role of humoral immunity in acute rejection in solid organ transplantation remains controversial, although it is known that the presence of antidonor antibodies may precipitate graft rejection. We investigated the clinical relevance of antidonor humoral immunity for living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) by means of flow cytometry crossmatch (FCXM).

METHODS

T cell FCXM using fresh donor peripheral lymphocytes was performed before and up to 1 month after LDLT in 58 patients. Ten patients received ABO-incompatible grafts. IgM and IgG antidonor antibodies were analyzed in relation to clinical acute rejection as defined by liver function tests with or without histological evidence.

RESULTS

Pretransplantation FCXM was positive for five patients (8.6%), resulting in two cases of positive posttransplantation FCXM and two rejection episodes. Twelve patients (20.7%) showed positive posttransplantation FCXM. The incidence of acute rejection within 1 month was 100% in FCXM-positive patients and 17.4% in FCXM-negative patients (P<0.001). Thirteen (76.5%) of 17 rejection episodes in ABO-compatible cases were associated with concomitant antidonor IgM antibody. IgG antibody was also identified in six of these episodes. Antidonor antibodies disappeared after rejection treatments in all cases, but with some delay in clinical improvement. On the other hand, no antidonor antibodies were detected in any of the four rejection episodes in ABO-incompatible cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Early acute rejection in LDLT is significantly associated with antidonor T cell antibody formation in ABO-compatible cases. This suggests a definite role for donor-specific humoral immunity in acute rejection. Rejection episodes without antidonor antibodies may suggest graft injury by pure cellular immunity, or possibly the presence of humoral immunity triggered by antigens not present on donor T cells.