Mackay F J, Pearce G L, Mann R D
Drug Safety Research Unit, Southampton, UK.
Br J Clin Pharmacol. 1999 Jan;47(1):111-4. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2125.1999.00855.x.
Cough is one of the most frequent side effects associated with angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEIs) but is not thought to be associated with losartan, an angiotensin II receptor antagonist (ARA). This study compares reports of cough with losartan and three ACEIs used in general practice.
Studies have been conducted for losartan, and three ACEIs enalapril, lisinopril and perindopril, using the technique of Prescription-Event Monitoring. Patients were identified using dispensed prescription data. Questionnaires were sent to patients' general practitioners 6 months after the date of first prescription. Cases of cough within the first 60 days of treatment with losartan resulting in withdrawal of the drug were followed up with additional questionnaires. Incidence rates for reports of cough were calculated. In order to reduce the impact of carry-over effects, rate ratios were calculated for first reports of cough between days 8 and 60 using losartan as the index drug.
The cohort for each drug exceeded 9000 patients. Age and sex distributions and indications for prescribing the four drugs were similar. Cough was the most frequent reason for discontinuation of losartan and the most frequently reported event in the first month of treatment with this drug. When reports of cough between days 1-7 were excluded, rates of cough were significantly higher for the three ACEIs when compared with losartan (rate ratios 1.5, 4.8 and 5.7, all P<0.03). 101 patients had discontinued losartan due to cough. 91% of these had previously been prescribed an ACEI and 86% had previously experienced ACEI cough.
Carry-over accounted for the observed excess of reports of cough with losartan. Rates of cough between days 8 and 60 were significantly higher for the three ACEIs compared with losartan. Confounding factors associated with comparative observational cohort studies are discussed.
咳嗽是血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂(ACEI)最常见的副作用之一,但一般认为与血管紧张素II受体拮抗剂(ARA)氯沙坦无关。本研究比较了氯沙坦与三种全科医疗中使用的ACEI引发咳嗽的报告情况。
采用处方事件监测技术对氯沙坦以及三种ACEI(依那普利、赖诺普利和培哚普利)进行了研究。利用配药处方数据识别患者。在首次处方日期6个月后向患者的全科医生发送问卷。对氯沙坦治疗前60天内因咳嗽导致停药的病例,通过额外问卷进行随访。计算咳嗽报告的发生率。为减少遗留效应的影响,以氯沙坦为参照药物,计算第8天至60天咳嗽首次报告的率比。
每种药物的队列均超过9000例患者。四种药物的年龄、性别分布及处方适应证相似。咳嗽是氯沙坦停药的最常见原因,也是该药物治疗第一个月报告最多的事件。排除第1 - 7天的咳嗽报告后,三种ACEI的咳嗽发生率显著高于氯沙坦(率比分别为1.5、4.8和5.7,P均<0.03)。101例患者因咳嗽停用氯沙坦。其中91%之前曾服用过ACEI,86%之前有过ACEI引发的咳嗽。
遗留效应导致氯沙坦咳嗽报告出现额外增加。与氯沙坦相比,三种ACEI在第8天至60天的咳嗽发生率显著更高。讨论了与比较性观察队列研究相关的混杂因素。