Brown M C, Guest J F
CATALYST Health Economics Consultants, Pinner, Middlesex, UK.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 1999 Feb;43 ( Pt 1):30-7. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2788.1999.43120176.x.
The aim of the present study was to estimate the direct healthcare cost of managing adults with previously untreated phenylketonuria (PKU) for one year before any dietary restrictions and for the first year after a phenylalanine- (PHE-) restricted diet was introduced. The resource use and corresponding costs were estimated from medical records and interviews with health care professionals experienced in caring for adults with previously untreated PKU. The mean annual cost of caring for a client being fed an unrestricted diet was estimated to be 83 996 pound silver. In the first year after introducing a PHE-restricted diet, the mean annual cost was reduced by 20 647 pound silver to 63 348 pound silver as a result of a reduction in nursing time, hospitalizations, outpatient clinic visits and medications. However, the economic benefit of the diet depended on whether the clients were previously high or low users of nursing care. Nursing time was the key cost-driver, accounting for 79% of the cost of managing high users and 31% of the management cost for low users. In contrast, the acquisition cost of a PHE-restricted diet accounted for up to 6% of the cost for managing high users and 15% of the management cost for low users. Sensitivity analyses showed that introducing a PHE-restricted diet reduces the annual cost of care, provided that annual nursing time was reduced by more than 8% or more than 5% of clients respond to the diet. The clients showed fewer negative behaviours when being fed a PHE-restricted diet, which may account for the observed reduction in nursing time needed to care for these clients. In conclusion, feeding a PHE-restricted diet to adults with previously untreated PKU leads to economic benefits to the UK's National Health Service and society in general.
本研究的目的是估算在未进行任何饮食限制之前,对未经治疗的成年苯丙酮尿症(PKU)患者进行一年管理的直接医疗费用,以及在引入苯丙氨酸(PHE)限制饮食后的第一年的费用。资源使用情况及相应成本是根据医疗记录以及对照顾未经治疗的成年PKU患者经验丰富的医护人员的访谈估算得出的。对食用无限制饮食的患者进行护理的年均费用估计为83996英镑。在引入PHE限制饮食后的第一年,由于护理时间、住院次数、门诊就诊次数和药物费用的减少,年均费用降低了20647英镑,降至63348英镑。然而,饮食的经济效益取决于患者之前是高护理使用者还是低护理使用者。护理时间是关键的成本驱动因素,占高护理使用者管理成本的79%,占低护理使用者管理成本的31%。相比之下,PHE限制饮食的购置成本占高护理使用者管理成本的比例高达6%,占低护理使用者管理成本的15%。敏感性分析表明,引入PHE限制饮食可降低护理的年度成本,前提是年度护理时间减少超过8%,或者超过5%的患者对该饮食有反应。食用PHE限制饮食的患者出现的负面行为较少,这可能解释了观察到的照顾这些患者所需护理时间的减少。总之,对未经治疗的成年PKU患者采用PHE限制饮食,总体上会给英国国家医疗服务体系和社会带来经济效益。