Alaniz C, Stumpf J L, Townsend K A
University of Michigan Medical Center and College of Pharmacy, Ann Arbor.
Hosp Pharm. 1991 Aug;26(8):707-10, 719.
Because of increasing norfloxacin use and the development of resistant organisms, an evaluation was undertaken in a University Hospital to assess the appropriateness of norfloxacin for the treatment of urinary tract infections and to calculate the potential cost savings associated with more cost-effective antibiotic therapy. Medical records of 64 patients receiving norfloxacin for a 31-day period were concurrently reviewed. Of these, 58 patients were treated for urinary tract infections and four patients received urinary tract infection prophylaxis. Fourteen patients were prescribed solely empiric therapy whereas an additional 44 patients received definitive treatment confirmed by culture results. Based on the predetermined criteria, norfloxacin use for the definitive treatment of urinary tract infections was deemed to be appropriate in 34 of the 44 patients. Three additional courses of therapy were also judged to be appropriate due to documented signs and symptoms associated with urinary tract infections, despite cultures with less than 10(5) colony forming units per mL urine. Reasons for inappropriate use in the remaining seven patients included isolation of fewer bacteria than required by the criteria in asymptomatic patients (3 cases), isolation of organisms not sensitive to norfloxacin (1 case) and lack of dosage adjustment for renal insufficiency (3 cases). Nineteen of 32 evaluable inpatients (59%) received norfloxacin when a less expensive, equally effective agent was available. Although savings from more cost-effective therapy of urinary tract infections are minimal, due to the potential emergence of resistant organisms, norfloxacin should be reserved for infections not amenable to treatment with other oral antibiotics.
由于诺氟沙星使用的增加以及耐药菌的出现,一家大学医院进行了一项评估,以评估诺氟沙星治疗尿路感染的合理性,并计算与更具成本效益的抗生素治疗相关的潜在成本节约。同时回顾了64例接受诺氟沙星治疗31天的患者的病历。其中,58例患者接受尿路感染治疗,4例患者接受尿路感染预防。14例患者仅接受经验性治疗,另外44例患者接受了培养结果证实的确定性治疗。根据预定标准,44例患者中有34例使用诺氟沙星进行尿路感染的确定性治疗被认为是合适的。尽管每毫升尿液中培养出的菌落形成单位少于10⁵,但由于记录到与尿路感染相关的体征和症状,另外三个疗程的治疗也被判定为合适。其余7例患者使用不当的原因包括无症状患者中分离出的细菌少于标准要求(3例)、分离出对诺氟沙星不敏感的微生物(1例)以及肾功能不全时未调整剂量(3例)。32例可评估的住院患者中有19例(59%)在有更便宜、同样有效的药物时使用了诺氟沙星。尽管通过更具成本效益的尿路感染治疗节省的费用很少,但由于可能出现耐药菌,诺氟沙星应保留用于其他口服抗生素无法治疗的感染。