Madej T H, Jackson I J, Wheatley R G, Wilson J
York District General Hospital.
Qual Health Care. 1993 Mar;2(1):31-4. doi: 10.1136/qshc.2.1.31.
To assess the impact of introducing spinal anaesthesia for obstetric operative procedures on use of general anaesthesia and quality of regional anaesthesia in a unit with an established epidural service a retrospective analysis of routinely collected data on method of anaesthesia, efficacy, and complications was carried out. Data were collected from 1988 to 1991 on 1670 obstetric patients requiring an operative procedure. The introduction of spinal anaesthesia in 1989 significantly reduced the proportion of operative procedures performed under general anaesthesia, from 60% (234/390) in 1988 to 30% (124/414) in 1991. The decrease was most pronounced for manual removal of the placenta (88%, 48/55 v 9%, 3/34) and emergency caesarean section (67%, 129/193) v 38%, 87/229). Epidural anaesthesia decreased in use most significantly for elective caesarean section (65%, 77/118 v 3% 3/113; x2=139, p<0.0001). The incidence of severe pain and need for conversion to general anaesthesia was significantly less with spinal anaesthesia (0%, 0/207 v 3%, 5/156; p<0.05). Hypotension was not a problem, and the incidence of headache after spinal anaesthetic decreased over the period studied. Introducing spinal anaesthesia therefore reduced the need for general anaesthesia and improved the quality of regional anaesthesia.
为评估在一个已开展硬膜外麻醉服务的科室中,引入脊髓麻醉用于产科手术对全身麻醉的使用及区域麻醉质量的影响,我们对常规收集的关于麻醉方法、疗效及并发症的数据进行了回顾性分析。收集了1988年至1991年期间1670例需要进行手术的产科患者的数据。1989年引入脊髓麻醉后,全身麻醉下进行的手术比例显著降低,从1988年的60%(234/390)降至1991年的30%(124/414)。这种下降在人工剥离胎盘(88%,48/55对9%,3/34)和急诊剖宫产(67%,129/193对38%,87/229)中最为明显。择期剖宫产中硬膜外麻醉的使用下降最为显著(65%,77/118对3%,3/113;x2=139,p<0.0001)。脊髓麻醉时严重疼痛的发生率及转为全身麻醉的需求显著更低(0%,0/207对3%,5/156;p<0.05)。低血压不是问题,在研究期间脊髓麻醉后头痛的发生率有所下降。因此,引入脊髓麻醉减少了对全身麻醉的需求并改善了区域麻醉的质量。