Vingilis E, Brown U, Koeppen R, Hennen B, Bass M, Peyton K, Downe J, Stewart M
Population and Community Health Unit, Faculty of Medicine, University of Western Ontario, London, Canada.
Health Educ Res. 1998 Mar;13(1):33-46. doi: 10.1093/her/13.1.33.
The purpose of the study was to evaluate an Ontario Ministry of Health (MOH) cold/flu self-care public education campaign to reduce unnecessary patient visits to doctors. The MOH campaign consisted of an information booklet delivered to every household in an Ontario city, newspaper ads and radio spots. The program ran during January-March 1994. The evaluation consisted of: (1) 2x2 telephone survey in London (experimental area) and Windsor (comparison area), before and during the campaign; and (2) a telephone survey of London family practitioners during the campaign. In addition, data on the incidence of cold/flu visits to three hospital emergency departments and a sample of family physicians' offices were gathered. The data suggest that program rationale may have been questionable because the majority of the surveyed public were knowledgeable and self-reported appropriate doctor visits for cold/flu. Campaign evaluation showed limited impact. Message penetration was low; only one-third of London residents knew of the campaign or read the booklet. Only two of 10 questions showed increases in knowledge in London and no changes were found for beliefs, attitudes, acquisition of new health practices or self-reported visits to the doctor. The physician survey, emergency room and family physician office visit data were consistent with the public survey findings.
该研究的目的是评估安大略省卫生部(MOH)开展的一项感冒/流感自我护理公共教育活动,以减少患者不必要的就医次数。卫生部的活动包括向安大略省一个城市的每户家庭发放一本信息手册、报纸广告和广播节目。该项目于1994年1月至3月期间开展。评估包括:(1)在活动开展前和开展期间,对伦敦(试验区)和温莎(对照区)进行2×2电话调查;(2)在活动开展期间对伦敦的家庭医生进行电话调查。此外,还收集了三家医院急诊科感冒/流感就诊率的数据以及家庭医生办公室的样本数据。数据表明,该项目的理论依据可能存在问题,因为大多数接受调查的公众具备相关知识,且自我报告的感冒/流感就医情况合理。活动评估显示影响有限。信息传播程度较低;只有三分之一的伦敦居民知晓该活动或阅读了手册。在伦敦,10个问题中只有两个显示知识有所增加,在信念、态度、采用新的健康行为或自我报告的就医情况方面未发现变化。医生调查、急诊室和家庭医生办公室就诊数据与公众调查结果一致。