Bird J C, Beynon G J, Prevost A T, Baguley D M
Audiology Department, Addenbrooke's NHS Trust, Cambridge.
Br J Gen Pract. 1998 Dec;48(437):1828-32.
The majority of balance disorders are non life-threatening and symptoms will resolve spontaneously. However, some patients require further investigation and many disorders may benefit from specialist treatment it is unclear whether appropriate identification and referral of this group of patients presently occurs.
To review the management of patients with symptoms of dizziness within primary care.
A retrospective review of the management of 503 patients who visited their general practitioner (GP) complaining of dizziness between August 1993 and July 1995. Management was then compared with local criteria.
On average, 2.2% of patients per year at the practices studied consulted their GP about dizziness, amounting to 0.7% of all consultations. The most common GP diagnosis was of an ear, nose, and throat (ENT) disorder (33.8%). Similarly, many of the 16% referred were directed to ENT (36%) specialists. The proportion of patients referred was significantly higher in those seeing their GP at least twice, those with symptoms lasting a year or more, or where there were additional symptoms associated with the dizziness, indicative of a cardiac, ENT, or neurological disorder. Compared with the local criteria, 17% of management decisions were deemed inappropriate. The major failing was not referring appropriate patients. This group comprised patients with chronic, non-urgent symptoms, and were significantly older than those appropriately referred.
Patients with chronic symptoms of dizziness, particularly the elderly, are under-referred for specialist consultation and, therefore, do not have access to appropriate treatment regimes. This suggests a need for further training of GPs and evaluation of therapeutic needs of elderly dizzy patients.
大多数平衡失调不会危及生命,症状会自行缓解。然而,一些患者需要进一步检查,许多失调可能受益于专科治疗,目前尚不清楚这组患者是否得到了恰当的识别和转诊。
回顾初级保健中头晕症状患者的管理情况。
对1993年8月至1995年7月间因头晕症状就诊于全科医生(GP)的503例患者的管理情况进行回顾性研究。然后将管理情况与当地标准进行比较。
在所研究的诊所中,每年平均有2.2%的患者因头晕咨询全科医生,占所有咨询的0.7%。全科医生最常见的诊断是耳鼻喉(ENT)疾病(33.8%)。同样,在转诊的16%患者中,许多人被转诊至耳鼻喉专科医生(36%)。至少就诊两次的患者、症状持续一年或更长时间的患者,或伴有与头晕相关的其他症状(提示心脏、耳鼻喉或神经系统疾病)的患者中,转诊患者的比例明显更高。与当地标准相比,17%的管理决策被认为不恰当。主要不足在于未转诊合适的患者。这组患者有慢性非紧急症状,且年龄明显大于得到恰当转诊的患者。
有慢性头晕症状的患者,尤其是老年人,转诊至专科咨询的比例较低,因此无法获得适当的治疗方案。这表明需要对全科医生进行进一步培训,并评估老年头晕患者的治疗需求。