Barenfanger J, Drake C, Kacich G
Laboratory Medicine, Memorial Medical Center, Springfield, Illinois 62781, USA.
J Clin Microbiol. 1999 May;37(5):1415-8. doi: 10.1128/JCM.37.5.1415-1418.1999.
To assess the expected clinical and financial benefits of rapid reporting of microbiology results, we compared patients whose cultured samples were processed in the normal manner to patients whose samples were processed more rapidly due to a minor change in work flow. For the samples tested in the rapid-reporting time period, the vast majority of bacterial identification and antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) results were verified with the Vitek system on the same day that they were available. This time period was called rapid AST (RAST). For RAST, a technologist on the evening shift verified the data that became available during that shift. For the control time period, cultures were processed in the normal manner (normal AST [NAST]), which did not include evening-shift verification. For NAST, the results for approximately half of the cultures were verified on the first day that the result was available. The average turnaround time for the reporting of AST results was 39.2 h for RAST and 44.4 h for NAST (5.2 h faster for RAST [P = 0.001]). Subsequently, physicians were able to initiate appropriate antimicrobial therapy sooner for patients whose samples were tested as part of RAST (P = 0.006). The mortality rates were 7. 9 and 9.6% for patients whose samples were tested as part of RAST and NAST, respectively (P = 0.45). The average length of stay was 10. 7 days per patient for RAST and 12.6 days for NAST, a difference of 2.0 days less for RAST (P = 0.006). The average variable cost was $4, 927 per patient for RAST and $6,677 for NAST, a difference of $1,750 less per patient for RAST (P = 0.001). This results in over $4 million in savings in variable costs per year in our hospital.
为评估微生物学结果快速报告的预期临床和经济效益,我们将培养样本按常规方式处理的患者与因工作流程的微小变化而样本处理速度更快的患者进行了比较。对于在快速报告时间段内检测的样本,绝大多数细菌鉴定和抗菌药物敏感性试验(AST)结果在获得结果的同一天通过Vitek系统得到验证。这个时间段称为快速AST(RAST)。对于RAST,晚班技术人员会验证该班次期间获得的数据。在对照时间段,培养物按常规方式处理(常规AST [NAST]),其中不包括晚班验证。对于NAST,大约一半培养物的结果在结果获得的第一天得到验证。AST结果报告的平均周转时间RAST为39.2小时,NAST为44.4小时(RAST快5.2小时 [P = 0.001])。随后,对于样本作为RAST一部分进行检测的患者,医生能够更快地开始适当的抗菌治疗(P = 0.006)。样本作为RAST和NAST一部分进行检测的患者的死亡率分别为7.9%和9.6%(P = 0.45)。RAST每位患者的平均住院时间为10.7天,NAST为12.6天,RAST少2.0天(P = 0.006)。RAST每位患者的平均可变成本为4927美元,NAST为6677美元,RAST每位患者少1750美元(P = 0.001)。这使得我们医院每年在可变成本方面节省超过400万美元。