Bilateral Wilms' tumor: a clinicopathologic review.

Bilateral Wilms' tumor occurs at a younger age than unilateral disease. While it generally has a good prognosis, it presents a therapeutic dilemma to balance curative surgical resection with preservation of renal tissue. A 15 year review of bilateral Wilms' tumors diagnosed at Princess Margaret Hospital was undertaken. Of 46 Wilms' tumor cases, eight were designated bilateral by diagnostic imaging (median age 1.1 years compared with 3.5 years for unilateral tumors). The surgical management entailed primary nephrectomy with contralateral biopsy in two patients, and bilateral biopsy and delayed resection in all remaining surviving patients (one patient died of perioperative complications). Seven patients had localized disease (stage I/II) and the six surviving patients received chemotherapy with vincristine and actinomycin; no patient received radiotherapy. All are alive and well (median follow-up 5.1 years). The remaining patient presented with pulmonary metastases and died of disease progression. Pathologic review revealed that four patients had truly bilateral disease demonstrable by histology, three had unilateral Wilms' tumor with contralateral nephrogenic rests, and in one patient the biopsies of the contralateral kidney showed neither tumor nor nephrogenic rests. In most cases pathological material was subject to external review. Follow-up demonstrates excellent renal function with compensatory hypertrophy in the remaining renal tissue. Conservative surgery and simple out-patient based, low toxicity chemotherapy is curative in most patients.