Tudor W, Tudor J, Gove W R
Soc Forces. 1979 Mar;57(3):871-86. doi: 10.1093/sf/57.3.871.
This paper investigates the thesis that sex role definitions in the U.S. support a double standard in societal reactions to mental incompetence. Role expectations for women are such that females are generally expected to be less competent than males in a variety of instrumental tasks, although perhaps more expressive. Males in turn are expected to be more active and aggressive than females in their exercise of the greater power and responsibility ascribed to them. In light of these generalized expectations we suggest that incompetence in instrumental fields is more disturbing when demonstrated by males, and we hypothesize that societal reactions to the mental deficiencies of males are more prompt and severe. The paper supports this hypothesis with data suggesting that mentally retarded males are more likely to be institutionalized than retarded females, and that males tend to be institutionalized at earlier ages and for milder disorders. It is noted that these data are consistent with previously reported data on mental illness.
美国的性别角色定义在社会对精神不健全的反应中支持双重标准。对女性的角色期望是,尽管女性在各种工具性任务中可能更具表现力,但总体上人们认为她们不如男性有能力。反过来,人们期望男性在行使赋予他们的更大权力和责任时,比女性更积极、更有进取心。鉴于这些普遍期望,我们认为,工具性领域的不称职由男性表现出来时更令人不安,并且我们假设社会对男性精神缺陷的反应更迅速、更严厉。本文用数据支持了这一假设,这些数据表明,智力迟钝的男性比智力迟钝的女性更有可能被送进机构,而且男性往往在更早的年龄、因更轻微的病症就被送进机构。需要指出的是,这些数据与先前报道的有关精神疾病的数据是一致的。