Valeri G, Ferrara C, Carloni S, Soccetti A, Giovagnoni A
Cattedra di Radiologia, Università degli Studi, Ancona.
Radiol Med. 1999 Jan-Feb;97(1-2):19-25.
To investigate the clinical role of Magnetic Resonance Arthrography (MRA) of the wrist in subjects with chronic pain.
Thirty-five patients complaining of wrist pain for more 6 months were submitted to MRI and MRA. All patients received an intra-articular (monocompartment radiocarpal joint) injection of 2-10 mL of a 10 mmol saline solution of Gd-DPTA. Two radiologists independently evaluated the conspicuity of the intrinsic intercarpal ligaments and of the triangular fibrocartilage complex and expressed it on a 3-grade semiquantitative scale. On MRI images, complete visualization of the two structures was graded as 0, partial visualization as 1 and no visualization as 2. On MRA images, no contrast agent passage through the ligament or the complex was graded as 0, minimal passage as 1 and complete passage as 2. Sixteen patients had surgical confirmation (arthroscopy in 10 and open surgery in 6 patients).
On MRI images the scapholunate ligament was completely visualized in 7 patients (21%) and partially or not visualized in 28 patients (89%). MRA images showed an intact ligament in 15 cases (44%) and a partial or total tear in 20 cases (48% and 8% respectively, 56% in all). On MRI images the luno-pyramidal ligament was completely visualized in 6 patients (18%) and partially or not visualized in 29 cases (82%). On MRA images the luno-pyramidal ligament was intact in 21 cases (58%) and had a partial or total tear in 14 cases (27% and 15% respectively, 42% in all). On MRI images the triangular fibrocartilage complex was normal in 27 cases (76%) and it was only partially visualized in 8 cases (24%). On MRA images the triangular fibrocartilage complex was normal in 13 cases (37%) and had a partial injury in 22 cases (63%). There were no severe side-effects to contrast agent injection, nor severe complications. The overall diagnostic accuracy rates of MRI and MRA were 40% and 81% respectively, with sensitivity and specificity of 63% and 39% (MRI) and of 82% and 79% (MRA).
Compared with MRI, MRA can be considered a useful tool for the visualization of interosseous carpal ligaments and of the triangular fibrocartilage complex. MRA also helps detect injuries in these structures.
探讨腕关节磁共振关节造影(MRA)在慢性疼痛患者中的临床作用。
35例腕部疼痛超过6个月的患者接受了MRI和MRA检查。所有患者均接受了2 - 10 mL的10 mmol钆喷酸葡胺生理盐水溶液关节内(单室桡腕关节)注射。两名放射科医生独立评估腕骨间固有韧带和三角纤维软骨复合体的显影情况,并以3级半定量量表表示。在MRI图像上,两种结构完全显影评为0级,部分显影评为1级,未显影评为2级。在MRA图像上,对比剂未通过韧带或复合体评为0级,少量通过评为1级,完全通过评为2级。16例患者有手术证实(10例关节镜检查,6例开放手术)。
在MRI图像上,7例(21%)患者的舟月韧带完全显影,28例(89%)患者部分显影或未显影。MRA图像显示15例(44%)韧带完整,20例(分别为48%和8%,共56%)部分或完全撕裂。在MRI图像上,6例(18%)患者的月三角韧带完全显影,29例(82%)患者部分显影或未显影。在MRA图像上,21例(58%)患者的月三角韧带完整,14例(分别为27%和15%,共42%)部分或完全撕裂。在MRI图像上,27例(76%)患者的三角纤维软骨复合体正常,8例(24%)仅部分显影。在MRA图像上,13例(37%)患者的三角纤维软骨复合体正常,22例(63%)有部分损伤。对比剂注射无严重副作用,也无严重并发症。MRI和MRA的总体诊断准确率分别为40%和81%,敏感性和特异性分别为63%和39%(MRI)以及82%和79%(MRA)。
与MRI相比,MRA可被视为一种用于显示腕骨间韧带和三角纤维软骨复合体的有用工具。MRA也有助于检测这些结构的损伤。