Schwid H A, Rooke G A, Ross B K, Sivarajan M
Department of Anesthesiology, University of Washington, and Veterans Administration Puget Sound Health Care System, Seattle 98108, USA.
Crit Care Med. 1999 Apr;27(4):821-4. doi: 10.1097/00003246-199904000-00045.
To determine whether an advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) computer simulation program improves retention of ACLS guidelines more effectively than textbook review.
Randomized, controlled trial.
Academic medical center.
Forty-five anesthesia residents and faculty tested 10 to 11 months after ACLS provider course training.
Participants were randomized and asked to prepare for a mock resuscitation (Mega Code) with either textbooks or a computerized ACLS simulation program.
Performance on a standardized Mega Code examination that required application of supraventricular tachycardia, ventricular fibrillation, and second-degree Type II atrioventricular block algorithms. Mega Code sessions were administered by an instructor who was blinded as to the subject group. The sessions were videotaped and scored by two evaluators who also were blinded as to the subject group.
Participants who used the ACLS simulation program scored significantly higher (mean 34.9 +/- 5.0 [SD] of 47 possible points) than participants who reviewed using a textbook (29.2 +/- 4.9); p < .001. Pass-fail rates for the algorithms were also higher for the group that reviewed with the simulator (mean 2.5 +/- 0.5 of 3 possible passes) than the group that used the textbook (1.6 +/- 1.0); p = .001.
Use of a computerized ACLS simulation program improves retention of ACLS guidelines better than textbook review.
确定高级心脏生命支持(ACLS)计算机模拟程序在提高ACLS指南记忆方面是否比教科书复习更有效。
随机对照试验。
学术医疗中心。
45名麻醉住院医师和教员在ACLS提供者课程培训后10至11个月接受测试。
参与者被随机分组,并被要求使用教科书或ACLS计算机模拟程序为模拟复苏(大型模拟急救)做准备。
在标准化大型模拟急救考试中的表现,该考试要求应用室上性心动过速、心室颤动和二度II型房室传导阻滞算法。大型模拟急救课程由一名对受试者分组情况不知情的教员进行。课程进行录像,并由两名同样对受试者分组情况不知情的评估人员评分。
使用ACLS模拟程序的参与者得分显著高于使用教科书复习的参与者(47分满分,平均34.9±5.0[标准差])(29.2±4.9);p<0.001。使用模拟器复习的组算法的及格率(3次可能的及格中平均2.5±0.5次)也高于使用教科书的组(1.6±1.0次);p = 0.001。
使用ACLS计算机模拟程序在提高ACLS指南记忆方面比教科书复习效果更好。