Desnick L, Taplin S, Taylor V, Coole D, Urban N
University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, USA.
J Womens Health. 1999 Apr;8(3):389-97. doi: 10.1089/jwh.1999.8.389.
To assess predictors of reported performance of screening clinical breast examination (CBE) by internists, family physicians, and obstetrician/gynecologists, we surveyed members of these specialties in four counties of Washington State. We contacted all physicians in the counties and identified 334 providers who saw women ages 50-75 and provided primary care as their principal activity. Seventy-five percent (252 of 334) responded. Physicians were mailed a survey and contacted for telephone completion if they did not respond in writing. The survey inquired about their current performance of CBE and factors that might predispose, enable, or reinforce its use. Differences across specialties were assessed using the chi-square statistic. Factors associated with reported performance of screening CBE in > or =90% of women were evaluated using logistic regression. Fifty-one percent of physicians reported that they perform regular CBE on > or =90% of their patients, although the proportion varied across specialty type. Beliefs about the benefit of CBE were positive and similar across specialties. Twelve percent of male physicians, but no female physicians, reported that women's embarrassment affected their use of screening CBE. In a multivariate model, male gender, family practice specialty, and the perception of patient embarrassment were all associated with lower reported rates of performing regular CBE (p < 0.05). Work to increase the performance of CBE should consider the role of male physician embarrassment and family physician training. Ways to facilitate delivery of preventive care and factors influencing the women themselves may also be important to increased use of CBE.
为评估内科医生、家庭医生以及妇产科医生进行临床乳腺筛查检查(CBE)的报告表现的预测因素,我们对华盛顿州四个县的这些专业领域的成员进行了调查。我们联系了各县的所有医生,确定了334名主要从事初级保健工作且诊治50至75岁女性的医疗服务提供者。75%(334名中的252名)做出了回应。我们给医生们邮寄了调查问卷,如果他们没有书面回复,就通过电话联系以完成调查。该调查询问了他们目前进行CBE的情况以及可能促使、促成或强化其使用的因素。使用卡方统计量评估各专业之间的差异。使用逻辑回归评估与报告在≥90%的女性中进行筛查CBE相关的因素。51%的医生报告称他们对≥90%的患者进行常规CBE,尽管这一比例因专业类型而异。各专业对CBE益处的看法都是积极且相似的。12%的男医生报告称女性的尴尬情绪影响了他们进行筛查CBE,而女医生中无人这样报告。在多变量模型中,男性、家庭医学专业以及对患者尴尬情绪的认知均与报告的常规CBE执行率较低相关(p<0.05)。提高CBE执行率的工作应考虑男医生的尴尬情绪和家庭医生培训的作用。促进提供预防性护理的方法以及影响女性自身的因素对于增加CBE的使用可能也很重要。