Wyllie A, Zhang J F, Casswell S
Alcohol & Public Health Research Unit, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Addiction. 1998 Mar;93(3):361-71. doi: 10.1046/j.1360-0443.1998.9333615.x.
To examine the nature of the relationships between 10-17-year-old New Zealanders' responses to alcohol advertisements and their drinking behaviour and future drinking expectations, with consideration also being given to the role of positive and negative beliefs about drinking.
Survey involving 500 face-to-face interviews, with selection based on random cluster sampling.
In respondents' homes in New Zealand's three largest urban areas.
Ten-17-year-old New Zealanders.
Response to specific alcohol advertisements was measured by recalled exposure (how often they recalled having seen the advertisements) and liking (a measure of positive response).
An exploratory structural equation model provided tentative support for the theory-based hypothesis that positive responses to beer advertisements increased the frequency of current drinking and expected future drinking, among this age group. There was no evidence for the hypothesized reciprocal effects; the frequency of drinking (including non-drinking) did not significantly affect the respondent's liking of beer advertisements. There was also no support for a hypothesis that linking of the beer advertisements was a product of a general liking for alcohol. Many of the young people themselves felt that alcohol advertising encouraged teenagers to drink. This was especially the case among 10-13-year-old males, who were the most likely to accept the portrayals in alcohol advertising as realistic.
Although there are limitations on the confidence with which conclusions can be drawn, the findings are consistent with qualitative and quantitative research and different theoretical perspectives on advertising processes which suggest alcohol advertising is likely to have some influence on young people.
研究10至17岁新西兰人对酒精广告的反应与其饮酒行为及未来饮酒预期之间关系的本质,同时考虑对饮酒的积极和消极信念所起的作用。
采用随机整群抽样法选取500名受访者进行面对面访谈的调查。
在新西兰三大城市地区受访者的家中。
10至17岁的新西兰人。
通过回忆曝光度(他们回忆看到广告的频率)和喜好程度(积极反应的一种衡量方式)来测量对特定酒精广告的反应。
一个探索性结构方程模型为基于理论的假设提供了初步支持,即对啤酒广告的积极反应会增加该年龄组当前饮酒频率和预期未来饮酒频率。没有证据支持假设的相互影响;饮酒频率(包括不饮酒)并未显著影响受访者对啤酒广告的喜好程度。也没有支持啤酒广告关联是对酒精普遍喜好的产物这一假设。许多年轻人自己认为酒精广告鼓励青少年饮酒。10至13岁男性尤其如此,他们最有可能认为酒精广告中的描绘是现实的。
尽管得出结论的信心存在局限性,但研究结果与定性和定量研究以及关于广告过程的不同理论观点一致,这些研究表明酒精广告可能对年轻人有一定影响。