McCarley R W, Wible C G, Frumin M, Hirayasu Y, Levitt J J, Fischer I A, Shenton M E
Harvard Medical School, Department of Psychiatry, VA Medical Center, Brockton, Massachusetts 02401, USA.
Biol Psychiatry. 1999 May 1;45(9):1099-119. doi: 10.1016/s0006-3223(99)00018-9.
Structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data have provided much evidence in support of our current view that schizophrenia is a brain disorder with altered brain structure, and consequently involving more than a simple disturbance in neurotransmission. This review surveys 118 peer-reviewed studies with control group from 1987 to May 1998. Most studies (81%) do not find abnormalities of whole brain/intracranial contents, while lateral ventricle enlargement is reported in 77%, and third ventricle enlargement in 67%. The temporal lobe was the brain parenchymal region with the most consistently documented abnormalities. Volume decreases were found in 62% of 37 studies of whole temporal lobe, and in 81% of 16 studies of the superior temporal gyrus (and in 100% with gray matter separately evaluated). Fully 77% of the 30 studies of the medial temporal lobe reported volume reduction in one or more of its constituent structures (hippocampus, amygdala, parahippocampal gyrus). Despite evidence for frontal lobe functional abnormalities, structural MRI investigations less consistently found abnormalities, with 55% describing volume reduction. It may be that frontal lobe volume changes are small, and near the threshold for MRI detection. The parietal and occipital lobes were much less studied; about half of the studies showed positive findings. Most studies of cortical gray matter (86%) found volume reductions were not diffuse, but more pronounced in certain areas. About two thirds of the studies of subcortical structures of thalamus, corpus callosum and basal ganglia (which tend to increase volume with typical neuroleptics), show positive findings, as do almost all (91%) studies of cavum septi pellucidi (CSP). Most data were consistent with a developmental model, but growing evidence was compatible also with progressive, neurodegenerative features, suggesting a "two-hit" model of schizophrenia, for which a cellular hypothesis is discussed. The relationship of clinical symptoms to MRI findings is reviewed, as is the growing evidence suggesting structural abnormalities differ in affective (bipolar) psychosis and schizophrenia.
结构磁共振成像(MRI)数据为我们目前的观点提供了大量证据,即精神分裂症是一种脑结构改变的脑部疾病,因此不仅仅涉及简单的神经传递紊乱。这篇综述调查了1987年至1998年5月期间118项有对照组的同行评审研究。大多数研究(81%)未发现全脑/颅内内容物异常,而77%的研究报告侧脑室扩大,67%的研究报告第三脑室扩大。颞叶是脑实质区域中记录到异常最为一致的区域。在37项全颞叶研究中有62%发现体积减小,在16项颞上回研究中有81%发现体积减小(单独评估灰质时为100%)。在30项内侧颞叶研究中,足足77%报告其一个或多个组成结构(海马体、杏仁核、海马旁回)体积减小。尽管有证据表明额叶存在功能异常,但结构MRI研究发现异常的情况不太一致,55%的研究描述有体积减小。可能是额叶体积变化较小,接近MRI检测阈值。顶叶和枕叶的研究要少得多;约一半的研究有阳性发现。大多数皮质灰质研究(86%)发现体积减小并非弥漫性的,而是在某些区域更为明显。约三分之二的丘脑、胼胝体和基底神经节皮质下结构研究(这些结构通常会因使用典型抗精神病药物而体积增大)有阳性发现,几乎所有透明隔腔(CSP)研究(91%)也是如此。大多数数据与发育模型一致,但越来越多的证据也与进行性神经退行性特征相符,提示精神分裂症的“两次打击”模型,并对此进行了细胞假说的讨论。本文还综述了临床症状与MRI结果的关系,以及越来越多的证据表明情感性(双相)精神病和精神分裂症的结构异常存在差异。