Sandström E, Wahren B
Department of Dermatovenereology, Söder Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Lancet. 1999 May 22;353(9166):1735-42. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(98)06493-9.
The immune system's ability to scavenge and destroy detrimental HIV-1 products has an important effect on virion production and the course of infection. In earlier trials of therapeutic immunisation with envelope protein recombinant gp160 (rgp160) we observed a transient positive effect on CD4-lymphocyte counts. This randomised placebo-controlled study investigated whether our preliminary findings represented a potential for a more benign clinical course.
835 HIV-seropositive patients from 20 centres in Sweden, Norway, and Finland with CD4-cell counts above 200/microL were randomly assigned to receive 160 microg rgp160 or placebo (alum adjuvant alone) every 3 months for 3 years after an induction period, as well as optimum available treatment. Analyses were by intention to treat.
63 of 416 vaccine-group patients and 61 of 419 placebo-group patients reached a primary clinical endpoint (AIDS-defining event or death); the time to first clinical endpoint did not differ between the groups (p=0.864). Significantly fewer vaccine-group patients than placebo-group patients reached the primary immunological endpoint of a decrease of more than 30% from baseline CD4-cell count (157 vs 189, p=0.03). A higher proportion of the vaccine group had CD4-cell counts higher than baseline at 6 months (167 vs 133, p=0.014). HIV-1-specific T-cell immune reactivity was induced in all vaccine recipients studied. No severe adverse events associated with the vaccine were noted during the study. There were significantly fewer deaths among the vaccine recipients than among the placebo-group patients at 2 years, but not at the end of the study.
Therapeutic immunisations with rgp160 have a modest effect on CD4-cell counts, but this treatment alone did not lead to clinical benefit when given in addition to best clinical practice at the time of the trial. Immunisation in conjunction with antiretroviral therapy was also effective, which strongly suggests that a combination with highly active therapy would improve the total effect.
免疫系统清除和破坏有害HIV-1产物的能力对病毒体产生及感染进程具有重要影响。在早期用包膜蛋白重组gp160(rgp160)进行治疗性免疫的试验中,我们观察到对CD4淋巴细胞计数有短暂的积极影响。这项随机安慰剂对照研究调查了我们的初步发现是否代表了更良性临床病程的可能性。
来自瑞典、挪威和芬兰20个中心的835名HIV血清阳性患者,其CD4细胞计数高于200/微升,在诱导期后每3个月随机分配接受160微克rgp160或安慰剂(仅铝佐剂),为期3年,并接受最佳可用治疗。分析采用意向性治疗。
416名疫苗组患者中的63名和419名安慰剂组患者中的61名达到主要临床终点(艾滋病定义事件或死亡);两组首次达到临床终点的时间无差异(p = 0.864)。达到主要免疫终点(CD4细胞计数较基线下降超过30%)的疫苗组患者明显少于安慰剂组患者(157例对189例,p = 0.03)。疫苗组在6个月时CD4细胞计数高于基线的比例更高(167例对133例,p = 0.014)。在所有研究的疫苗接受者中均诱导出了HIV-1特异性T细胞免疫反应性。研究期间未发现与疫苗相关的严重不良事件。在2年时,疫苗接受者中的死亡人数明显少于安慰剂组患者,但在研究结束时并非如此。
用rgp160进行治疗性免疫对CD4细胞计数有适度影响,但在试验时除最佳临床实践外单独给予这种治疗并未带来临床益处。免疫联合抗逆转录病毒疗法也有效,这强烈表明与高效疗法联合将改善总体效果。