Leppälä J, Kannus P, Sievänen H, Vuori I, Järvinen M
Accident and Trauma Research Center, UKK Institute for Health Promotion Research, Tampere, Finland.
J Bone Miner Res. 1999 Jun;14(6):988-93. doi: 10.1359/jbmr.1999.14.6.988.
High peak bone mass or density in early adulthood is an important protective factor against osteoporotic fractures in later life, but it is not known whether injuries on growing bones affect the attainment of peak bone mass and density. The purpose of this study was therefore to examine with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry the areal bone mineral density (BMD) of the injured and uninjured extremity (the femoral neck, trochanter area of the femur, distal femur, patella, proximal tibia, and distal tibia), lumbar spine, and distal radius of young adults with a history of early life tibial shaft fracture and to find out whether the fracture had affected the attainment of peak bone density of these patients. The second objective was to clarify whether any background or clinical follow-up variable would predict the BMD difference between the affected and unaffected extremity. Thus, the BMD and clinical status of 45 patients (34 men and 11 women), who had sustained a tibial shaft fracture in childhood or in adolescence (between 7 and 15 years of age) an average 11 years before the study, were examined. The results showed that the fracture had created a small but statistically significant injured-to-uninjured side BMD difference (proximal tibia -1.7%; p = 0.011, and distal tibia 2.6%; p = 0.014), while the other sites showed no significant side-to-side differences. There were neither significant differences in the spinal or radial BMDs between the patients and their age-, height-, and weight-matched healthy controls. A further analysis of the data showed that the better the muscle strength in the injured lower limb, the lower the side-to-side BMD deficit in the proximal tibia of the same limb (r = 0.51; p < 0.001). Smoking had a significant association with the relative BMD in the injured distal tibia (mean injured-to-uninjured side BMD difference: smokers 6.1% vs. nonsmokers -0.6%, p = 0.016). Also patient's age at the time of the injury showed an association: the younger the patient at the time of the injury, the lower the side-to-side BMD deficit in the injured distal tibia (r = -0.35; p = 0.048). In conclusion, this study indicates that early life tibial fracture leads to a small long-term BMD deficit in the fractured bone while the other sites of the skeleton seem not to be affected. Thus, a tibial shaft fracture sustained in childhood or adolescence seems to only marginally interfere the attainment of peak bone density, the important predictor of the osteoporotic fractures in later life.
成年早期的高骨峰值或骨密度是预防晚年骨质疏松性骨折的重要保护因素,但尚不清楚生长中的骨骼损伤是否会影响骨峰值和骨密度的获得。因此,本研究的目的是采用双能X线吸收法检测有早年胫骨干骨折病史的年轻成人受伤和未受伤肢体(股骨颈、股骨转子区、股骨远端、髌骨、胫骨近端和胫骨远端)、腰椎和桡骨远端的骨矿物质密度(BMD),以确定骨折是否影响了这些患者骨密度峰值的获得。第二个目标是明确是否有任何背景或临床随访变量可以预测患侧和未患侧肢体之间的骨密度差异。因此,对45例患者(34例男性和11例女性)的骨密度和临床状况进行了检查,这些患者在儿童期或青春期(7至15岁之间)平均在本研究前11年发生了胫骨干骨折。结果显示,骨折造成了患侧与未患侧之间骨密度的微小但具有统计学意义的差异(胫骨近端-1.7%;p=0.011,胫骨远端2.6%;p=0.014),而其他部位未显示出显著的左右差异。患者与年龄、身高和体重匹配的健康对照者在脊柱或桡骨骨密度方面也没有显著差异。对数据的进一步分析表明,受伤下肢的肌肉力量越强,同一肢体胫骨近端的左右骨密度差异越小(r=0.51;p<0.001)。吸烟与受伤胫骨远端的相对骨密度有显著关联(患侧与未患侧骨密度平均差异:吸烟者6.1%,非吸烟者-0.6%,p=0.016)。受伤时患者的年龄也显示出一种关联:受伤时患者越年轻,受伤胫骨远端的左右骨密度差异越低(r=-0.35;p=0.048)。总之,本研究表明,早年胫骨干骨折会导致骨折部位出现微小的长期骨密度不足,而骨骼的其他部位似乎未受影响。因此,儿童期或青春期发生的胫骨干骨折似乎只会轻微干扰骨密度峰值的获得,而骨密度峰值是晚年骨质疏松性骨折的重要预测指标。