Manetz T S, Meade B J
Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology, Medical College of Virginia/VCU, Richmond, USA.
Toxicol Sci. 1999 Apr;48(2):206-17. doi: 10.1093/toxsci/48.2.206.
These studies were conducted to investigate the potential use of a flow cytometric analysis method for the identification and differentiation of chemicals with the capacity to induce irritation, IgE- or T cell-mediated hypersensitivity responses. An initial study investigated the ability of equally sensitizing concentrations (determined by local lymph node assay) of IgE-mediated (Toluene Diisocyanate-TDI) and T cell-mediated (Dinitrofluorobenzene-DNFB) allergens to differentially modulate the IgE+B220+ population in the lymph nodes draining the dermal exposure site. Sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) was also tested as a nonsensitizing irritant control. Female B6C3F1 mice were dermally exposed once daily for 4 consecutive days, with the optimum time point for analysis determined by examining the IgE+B220+ population 8, 10, and 12 days post-initial chemical exposure. At the peak time point, day 10, the IgE+B220+ population was significantly elevated in TDI (41%), while moderately elevated in DNFB (18%) exposed animals when compared to the vehicle (0.8%), and remained unchanged in SLS (2.2%) exposed animals when compared to the ethanol control (2.5%). Experiments in our laboratory and others have demonstrated that the draining lymph node B220+ population becomes significantly elevated following exposure to allergens (IgE- and T cell-mediated), not irritants, allowing for their differentiation. An existing mouse ear swelling assay was used to identify chemical irritants. Therefore, using the endpoints of percent ear swelling, percent B220+ cells, and percent IgE+B220+ cells, a combined irritancy/phenotypic analysis assay was developed and tested with tetradecane (irritant), toluene diisocyanate, trimellitic anhydride (IgE-mediated allergens), benzalkonium chloride, dinitrofluorobenzene, oxazolone, and dinitrochlorobenzene (T cell-mediated allergens) over a range of concentrations. Based upon the pattern of response observed, a paradigm was developed for continued evaluation: Irritant exposure will result in significant ear swelling without altering the B220+ or IgE+B220+ populations. Exposure to sensitizers (IgE-mediated or T cell-mediated) will increase the B220+ population and the percent ear swelling will remain unchanged or will significantly increase, depending on the irritancy capacity of the chemical. Both the IgE+B220+ and B220+ populations will become elevated at the same test concentration following exposure to IgE-mediated, hypersensitivity inducing allergens. At its peak, the percent of IgE+B220+ cells will be equal to the percent of B220+ cells. The B220+ population will increase at a lower test concentration than the IgE+B220+ population, following exposure to T cell-mediated, hypersensitivity inducing allergens. At its peak, the percent of IgE+B220+ cells will reach less than half that of the percent of B220+ cells. The irritancy/phenotypic analysis method may represent a single murine assay able to identify and differentiate chemicals with the capacity to induce irritation, or IgE-mediated or T cell-mediated responses.
进行这些研究是为了调查一种流式细胞术分析方法在识别和区分具有诱导刺激、IgE或T细胞介导的超敏反应能力的化学物质方面的潜在用途。一项初步研究调查了IgE介导的(甲苯二异氰酸酯 - TDI)和T细胞介导的(二硝基氟苯 - DNFB)过敏原在同等致敏浓度(通过局部淋巴结试验确定)下对真皮暴露部位引流淋巴结中IgE + B220 +细胞群进行差异调节的能力。十二烷基硫酸钠(SLS)也作为非致敏性刺激对照进行了测试。雌性B6C3F1小鼠连续4天每天进行一次皮肤暴露,通过在初次化学暴露后第8、10和12天检查IgE + B220 +细胞群来确定最佳分析时间点。在第10天这个峰值时间点,与赋形剂组(0.8%)相比,TDI暴露组的IgE + B220 +细胞群显著升高(41%),DNFB暴露组适度升高(18%),而与乙醇对照组(2.5%)相比,SLS暴露组保持不变(2.2%)。我们实验室和其他实验室的实验表明,暴露于过敏原(IgE和T细胞介导的)而非刺激物后,引流淋巴结中的B220 +细胞群会显著升高,从而实现区分。使用现有的小鼠耳部肿胀试验来识别化学刺激物。因此,利用耳部肿胀百分比、B220 +细胞百分比和IgE + B220 +细胞百分比这些终点指标,开发了一种联合刺激性/表型分析试验,并在一系列浓度下用十四烷(刺激物)、甲苯二异氰酸酯、偏苯三酸酐(IgE介导的过敏原)、苯扎氯铵、二硝基氟苯、恶唑酮和二硝基氯苯(T细胞介导的过敏原)进行了测试。根据观察到的反应模式,制定了一个用于持续评估的范例:暴露于刺激物会导致耳部显著肿胀,而不会改变B220 +或IgE + B220 +细胞群。暴露于致敏剂(IgE介导或T细胞介导)会增加B220 +细胞群,耳部肿胀百分比将保持不变或显著增加,这取决于化学物质的刺激能力。暴露于IgE介导的超敏反应诱导性过敏原后,在相同测试浓度下,IgE + B220 +和B220 +细胞群都会升高。在峰值时,IgE + B220 +细胞百分比将等于B220 +细胞百分比。暴露于T细胞介导的超敏反应诱导性过敏原后,B220 +细胞群在比IgE + B220 +细胞群更低的测试浓度下增加。在峰值时,IgE + B220 +细胞百分比将达到不到B220 +细胞百分比的一半。刺激性/表型分析方法可能代表一种单一的小鼠试验,能够识别和区分具有诱导刺激、IgE介导或T细胞介导反应能力的化学物质。