Rzany B, Correia O, Kelly J P, Naldi L, Auquier A, Stern R
Department of Dermatology, Fakultät für Klinische Medizin Mannheim der Universität Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany.
Lancet. 1999 Jun 26;353(9171):2190-4. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(98)05418-x.
There is still controversy about whether all antiepileptic drugs are associated with the severe cutaneous reactions Stevens-Johnson syndrome (SJS) and toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN). We have studied the role of antiepileptic drugs in SJS and TEN, taking into account potential cofactors that might confound or modify the risk.
The case-control study in France, Italy, Germany, and Portugal identified cases of SJS/TEN that developed when the patient was not in hospital and were validated by an expert committee. Controls were patients admitted to the same hospital as the case for an acute illness or an elective procedure.
73 (21%) of the 352 SJS/TEN cases and 28 (2%) of the 1579 controls reported intake of antiepileptic drugs. Among the 73 exposed SJS and TEN patients, 36 reported intake of phenobarbital, 14 of phenytoin, 21 of carbamazepine, 13 of valproic acid, and three of lamotrigine. Risk was highest in the first 8 weeks after onset of treatment. For individual antiepileptic drugs the univariate relative risk of SJS/TEN for 8 weeks or less of use was 57 (95% CI 16-360; multivariate risk 59 [12-302]) for phenobarbital; 91 (26-infinity) for phenytoin; 120 (34-infinity) for carbamazepine; 25 (5.6-infinity) for lamotrigine, and 24 (5.9-infinity) for valproic acid. The result for valproic acid was based on four case users, all of whom reported concurrent use of other associate drugs. The univariate relative risk for more than 8 weeks of use was 6.2 (2.4-17.0; multivariate risk 2.1 [0.5-9.3]) for phenobarbital, 1.2 (0-5.4) for phenytoin, 0.4 (0.02-2.1) for carbamazepine, and 7.0 (2.4-21.0; multivariate risk 2.0 [0.3-15.0]) for valproic acid.
SJS and TEN are associated with short-term therapy with phenytoin, phenobarbital, and carbamazepine. The association with valproic acid seems to be confounded by concomitant short-term therapy with other causal drugs. Lamotrigine also has the potential for severe skin reactions. The period of increased risk is largely confined to the first 8 weeks of treatment.
关于所有抗癫痫药物是否都与严重皮肤反应史蒂文斯-约翰逊综合征(SJS)和中毒性表皮坏死松解症(TEN)相关仍存在争议。我们研究了抗癫痫药物在SJS和TEN中的作用,同时考虑了可能混淆或改变风险的潜在辅助因素。
在法国、意大利、德国和葡萄牙进行的病例对照研究确定了患者不在医院时发生的SJS/TEN病例,并由一个专家委员会进行了验证。对照是因急性疾病或择期手术与病例在同一医院住院的患者。
352例SJS/TEN病例中有73例(21%)和1579例对照中有28例(2%)报告服用了抗癫痫药物。在73例暴露于SJS和TEN的患者中,36例报告服用苯巴比妥,14例服用苯妥英,21例服用卡马西平,13例服用丙戊酸,3例服用拉莫三嗪。治疗开始后的前8周风险最高。对于个别抗癫痫药物,使用8周及以内时SJS/TEN的单变量相对风险,苯巴比妥为57(95%可信区间16 - 360;多变量风险59 [12 - 302]);苯妥英为91(26 - 无穷大);卡马西平为120(34 - 无穷大);拉莫三嗪为25(5.6 - 无穷大);丙戊酸为24(5.9 - 无穷大)。丙戊酸的结果基于4例使用该药物的病例,所有这些病例均报告同时使用了其他相关药物。使用超过8周时的单变量相对风险,苯巴比妥为6.2(2.4 - 17.0;多变量风险2.1 [0.5 - 9.3]),苯妥英为1.2(0 - 5.4),卡马西平为0.4(0.02 - 2.1),丙戊酸为7.0(2.4 - 21.0;多变量风险2.0 [0.3 - 15.0])。
SJS和TEN与苯妥英、苯巴比妥和卡马西平的短期治疗相关。与丙戊酸的关联似乎被其他致病药物的同时短期治疗所混淆。拉莫三嗪也有引发严重皮肤反应的可能性。风险增加期主要局限于治疗的前8周。