Burtscheidt W, Schwarz R, Redner C, Gaebel W
Rheinische Kliniken, Psychiatrische Klinik der Heinrich-Heine-Universität Düsseldorf.
Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr. 1999 Jun;67(6):274-80. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-994976.
Outpatient alcoholism treatment programs are widespread especially in the United States and in Great Britain. However, there still exist only a few experimental studies investigating the numerous questions arising from this field. In this still ongoing project 120 patients were randomly assigned to 3 different outpatient group therapy programs: unspecific supportive therapy and 2 forms of behavioural therapy--coping skills training [17] and cognitive therapy according to Beck [2]. The main hypotheses to be tested are that both forms of behavioural therapy will prove superior to supportive treatment and that patients with a comorbidity of personality disorders will profit in a different way from these differentiated intervention strategies. Treatment lasted 6 months; first results obtained after the termination of this period demonstrate the feasibility of the study design; patients undergoing behavioural therapy showed good compliance with few drop-outs and significantly higher rates of abstinence compared with supportive therapy. 60% of the patients suffer from a concomitant personality disorder (mostly of the dependent, insecure, and masochistic type). Nevertheless, statistically significant differences between the 2 behavioural therapy techniques could not be established; a positive correlation between personality disorders and relapse or attrition could be confirmed only for relapses occurring within the first 3 months of treatment.
门诊酒精成瘾治疗项目很普遍,尤其是在美国和英国。然而,针对该领域出现的众多问题,仍仅有少数实验研究。在这个仍在进行的项目中,120名患者被随机分配到3种不同的门诊团体治疗项目中:非特异性支持性治疗和两种行为治疗形式——应对技能训练[17]以及根据贝克方法进行的认知治疗[2]。有待检验的主要假设是,两种行为治疗形式都将被证明优于支持性治疗,并且患有共病性人格障碍的患者将从这些不同的干预策略中以不同方式获益。治疗持续6个月;在此阶段结束后获得的初步结果证明了研究设计的可行性;接受行为治疗的患者表现出良好的依从性,脱落率低,与支持性治疗相比,戒酒率显著更高。60%的患者患有共病性人格障碍(大多为依赖型、不安全型和受虐型)。然而,无法确定两种行为治疗技术之间存在统计学上的显著差异;仅在治疗的前3个月内发生的复发中,人格障碍与复发或脱落之间的正相关得到了证实。