Byington R P, Evans G W, Espeland M A, Applegate W B, Hunninghake D B, Probstfield J, Furberg C D
Department of Public Health Sciences, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC 27157-1063, USA.
Circulation. 1999 Jul 20;100(3):e14-7. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.100.3.e14.
Few clinical trials have documented the efficacy of preventive treatment in asymptomatic women.
Lovastatin and minidose warfarin were evaluated in a factorially designed, placebo-controlled, randomized trial. The primary outcome was 3-year change in the mean maximum intimal-medial thickness of the carotid arteries as measured by B-mode ultrasonography. Participants (n=919) were randomized to 1 of 4 treatment groups: lovastatin alone, warfarin alone, lovastatin+warfarin combination, or a double-placebo group. Eligible participants were asymptomatic for cardiovascular disease, with evidence of early carotid atherosclerosis and moderately elevated LDL cholesterol level. Almost half (n=445) of the participants were women. To avoid confounding, 117 women taking estrogen were excluded from analysis. Both sexes experienced reductions in disease progression with lovastatin; there was no evidence of an overall sex x treatment interaction (P=0.72). When estimates of the sex-specific results were examined post hoc, women experienced disease regression to the greatest extent with the lovastatin + warfarin combination (P=0.02), although the women on lovastatin alone also had a reduction in progression (P=0.09). Men experienced the greatest reduction with lovastatin alone (P=0.02), although there is a suggestion that warfarin may also reduce progression to some extent.
Lovastatin is beneficial in reducing disease progression in women and men. Warfarin has no effect in women, although it may reduce progression in men. In men, warfarin does not add to the benefit of lovastatin and has no advantage over lovastatin alone.
很少有临床试验记录预防性治疗对无症状女性的疗效。
在一项析因设计、安慰剂对照的随机试验中评估了洛伐他汀和小剂量华法林。主要结局是通过B型超声测量的颈动脉平均最大内膜中层厚度的3年变化。参与者(n = 919)被随机分为4个治疗组之一:单独使用洛伐他汀、单独使用华法林、洛伐他汀 + 华法林联合使用或双安慰剂组。符合条件的参与者无心血管疾病症状,有早期颈动脉粥样硬化证据且低密度脂蛋白胆固醇水平中度升高。几乎一半(n = 445)的参与者为女性。为避免混淆,117名服用雌激素的女性被排除在分析之外。洛伐他汀使男性和女性的疾病进展均有所减缓;没有证据表明存在总体的性别×治疗交互作用(P = 0.72)。在事后检查性别特异性结果的估计值时,洛伐他汀 + 华法林联合使用组的女性疾病消退程度最大(P = 0.02),尽管单独使用洛伐他汀的女性疾病进展也有所减缓(P = 0.09)。单独使用洛伐他汀的男性疾病进展减缓程度最大(P = 0.02),尽管有迹象表明华法林在一定程度上也可能减缓疾病进展。
洛伐他汀对减少男性和女性的疾病进展有益。华法林对女性无效,尽管它可能在男性中减缓疾病进展。在男性中,华法林不会增加洛伐他汀的益处,且与单独使用洛伐他汀相比没有优势。