Sniadack D H, Moscoso B, Aguilar R, Heath J, Bellini W, Chiu M C
International Branch, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Bull World Health Organ. 1999;77(7):545-52.
Only limited data are available on the impact of measles outbreak response immunization (ORI) in developing countries. We conducted a community survey in Espindola, a rural border community in northern Peru, following a measles outbreak and subsequent ORI to study the epidemiology and impact of the outbreak and to evaluate the costs and benefits of measles ORI. During the outbreak, 150 of the 553 Espindola residents developed clinical cases of measles. Adults accounted for 44.0% of cases, and were frequently identified as primary cases. The attack rate among all susceptible people was 45.5% and was highest (61.2%) for the 16-20 year age group. Among adults, significant risk factors for developing measles included being aged 16-20 years (relative risk [RR] = 3.06, 95% CI = 2.08, 4.49) and being male (RR = 1.73, 95% CI = 1.11, 2.71). Among serologically confirmed cases, 60.7% developed diarrhoea and 32.1% pneumonia. The overall case-fatality rate was 3.3%, but reached 19.1% in the 0-23-month age group. Failure to reach children through either routine immunization or national campaigns made this community vulnerable to the severe and extensive impact of measles virus importation. The ORI campaign targeted non-measles case children aged 6 months to 15 years, regardless of their previous immunization status, and was effective in terminating this measles outbreak and in preventing morbidity, loss of livelihood and death despite the involvement of large numbers of adults in measles transmission. The last measles case occurred within 3 weeks of completing ORI. The ORI campaign, which would have cost approximately US$ 3000 in 1998, saved as many as 1155 person-days of work among 77 adults, prevented an estimated 87 cases of diarrhoea and 46 cases of pneumonia, and averted 5 deaths.
关于发展中国家麻疹疫情应对免疫接种(ORI)的影响,现有的数据有限。在秘鲁北部一个边境农村社区埃斯平多拉发生麻疹疫情并随后开展ORI之后,我们进行了一项社区调查,以研究该疫情的流行病学特征和影响,并评估麻疹ORI的成本与效益。在疫情期间,埃斯平多拉553名居民中有150人出现麻疹临床病例。成人占病例的44.0%,且常被确定为原发病例。所有易感人群中的发病率为45.5%,16 - 20岁年龄组的发病率最高(61.2%)。在成人中,患麻疹的显著危险因素包括年龄在16 - 20岁(相对危险度[RR]=3.06,95%可信区间[CI]=2.08,4.49)以及男性(RR = 1.73,95%CI = 1.11,2.71)。在血清学确诊的病例中,60.7%出现腹泻,32.1%出现肺炎。总体病死率为3.3%,但在0 - 23个月年龄组中达到19.1%。由于未能通过常规免疫接种或全国性活动覆盖儿童,该社区易受麻疹病毒输入的严重和广泛影响。ORI活动针对6个月至15岁未患麻疹的儿童,无论其先前的免疫接种状况如何,并且有效地终止了此次麻疹疫情,预防了发病、生计损失和死亡,尽管有大量成人参与麻疹传播。最后一例麻疹病例在完成ORI后的3周内出现。1998年开展的ORI活动花费约3000美元,为77名成人节省了多达1155个工作日,预防了约87例腹泻和46例肺炎,并避免了5例死亡。