Majoie C B, Aramideh M, Hulsmans F J, Castelijns J A, van Beek E J, Ongerboer de Visser B W
Department of Radiology, Free University Hospital, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 1999 Jun-Jul;20(6):1119-25.
Previous studies have shown that clinical localization of trigeminal nerve lesions is inaccurate as compared with MR imaging findings. The purpose of our study was to ascertain the added value of electromyographic (EMG) investigation of the trigeminal nerve reflexes for the improvement of lesion localization and for the preselection of patients for MR imaging.
We reviewed the EMG studies of the trigeminal reflexes and the MR imaging studies of 20 patients with unilateral symptoms and signs related to the trigeminal nerve (40 trigeminal nerves examined). The results of the two studies were compared to assess the value of EMG in predicting MR imaging outcome. Lesion localization as demonstrated by EMG was compared with localization at MR imaging. MR imaging was used as the standard of reference.
Eight (40%) of 20 patients had MR imaging findings related to presenting trigeminal symptoms, including five brain stem lesions and three peripheral lesions. Fourteen (70%) of 20 patients had EMG abnormalities related to presenting symptoms and signs. For brain stem lesions, lesion localization as shown by EMG corresponded well with MR imaging findings. EMG yielded a sensitivity of 100%, a specificity of 81%, a positive predictive value of 57%, and a negative predictive value of 100% in predicting MR imaging results. Interobserver agreement was good for both the EMG reflex and MR imaging examinations.
Our data suggest that EMG recordings of the trigeminal reflexes can be used to exclude structural lesions in patients with symptoms related to the trigeminal nerve. When a lesion is localized in the brain stem with EMG, a tailored MR imaging examination of this region may be sufficient.
既往研究表明,与磁共振成像(MR)结果相比,三叉神经病变的临床定位并不准确。我们研究的目的是确定对三叉神经反射进行肌电图(EMG)检查在改善病变定位以及为MR成像预选患者方面的附加价值。
我们回顾了20例有单侧三叉神经相关症状和体征患者(共检查40条三叉神经)的三叉神经反射EMG研究及MR成像研究。比较两项研究结果以评估EMG在预测MR成像结果方面的价值。将EMG显示的病变定位与MR成像的定位进行比较。以MR成像作为参考标准。
20例患者中有8例(40%)的MR成像结果与所呈现的三叉神经症状相关,包括5例脑干病变和3例周围病变。20例患者中有14例(70%)的EMG异常与所呈现的症状和体征相关。对于脑干病变,EMG显示的病变定位与MR成像结果吻合良好。在预测MR成像结果方面,EMG的敏感性为100%,特异性为81%,阳性预测值为57%,阴性预测值为100%。观察者间对EMG反射和MR成像检查的一致性良好。
我们的数据表明,三叉神经反射的EMG记录可用于排除有三叉神经相关症状患者的结构性病变。当通过EMG将病变定位于脑干时,对该区域进行针对性的MR成像检查可能就足够了。