Schwind E L, Wolfe M, Greendale K, Misra L M, Pass K A, Wallerstein R
Cystic Fibrosis Center, Saint Vincent's Hospital, New York, NY, USA.
Genet Test. 1999;3(2):215-8. doi: 10.1089/gte.1999.3.215.
We surveyed clinical genetics centers to assess current cystic fibrosis (CF) screening practices with regard to clinical and laboratory aspects. The survey was developed by the CF committee of the Genetics Network of the Empire State, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands (GENES) to gauge changes in trends following the April, 1997, NIH Consensus Statement recommending the offering of CF carrier screening to all pregnant patients. Thirty-five of 45 Centers (78%) returned the survey, which was mailed in June, 1998. Sixteen centers currently offer population-based screening, whereas 19 centers do not. Reasons cited for not offering testing included the low risk for CF in ethnic groups served, lack of data about test sensitivity in the populations served, and the absence of CF screening policies in the current standards of care. Approximately half (56%) of genetics centers that are offering testing altered their screening policy following the NIH Consensus statement, either by offering screening to patients of higher-risk ethnicities or by offering it to all patients. Less than half of the Centers that offer routine carrier screening offer screening to all patients regardless of ethnicity. This report is an initial step in documenting and understanding the current service practices regarding CF carrier testing in a diverse region. Our conclusions: (1) Screening practices vary widely among genetic centers in the region. (2) The decision to offer routine CF carrier screening is largely based on ethnicity of the patient population served. (3) Methods used to screen pregnant women and their partners in this part of the country reflect the diversity of models employed throughout the United States. (4) CF screening practices in the GENES region have changed significantly following the April, 1997, NIH consensus statement.
我们对临床遗传学中心进行了调查,以评估当前囊性纤维化(CF)筛查在临床和实验室方面的实践情况。该调查由帝国州、波多黎各和美属维尔京群岛遗传学网络(GENES)的CF委员会开展,旨在评估1997年4月美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)共识声明建议对所有孕妇进行CF携带者筛查后趋势的变化。45个中心中有35个(78%)回复了于1998年6月邮寄的调查问卷。16个中心目前提供基于人群的筛查,而19个中心不提供。不提供检测的原因包括所服务种族群体中CF风险较低、缺乏所服务人群检测敏感性的数据以及当前护理标准中没有CF筛查政策。约一半(56%)提供检测的遗传学中心在NIH共识声明发布后改变了筛查政策,要么对高风险种族的患者进行筛查,要么对所有患者进行筛查。提供常规携带者筛查的中心中,不到一半的中心对所有患者进行筛查,无论其种族如何。本报告是记录和了解该多样化地区当前CF携带者检测服务实践的第一步。我们的结论如下:(1)该地区各遗传学中心的筛查实践差异很大。(2)是否提供常规CF携带者筛查的决定很大程度上基于所服务患者群体的种族。(3)该国这一地区用于筛查孕妇及其伴侣的方法反映了美国各地所采用模式的多样性。(4)1997年4月NIH共识声明发布后,GENES地区的CF筛查实践发生了显著变化。