Baheerathan M, Shah A
Charing Cross Hospital, London, UK.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 1999 Sep;14(9):767-75. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1099-1166(199909)14:9<767::aid-gps7>3.0.co;2-6.
The impact of two changes in service delivery (alteration in the admission policy of the medical unit and the introduction of a formal liaison component to a 'consultation only' liaison geriatric psychiatry service) on the associated liaison geriatric psychiatry service was examined in a naturalistic study. The main null hypothesis was that the referral rate would not be influenced by either change in service delivery.
The 30-month study period was divided into three phases defined by the two changes in service delivery. The impact of the two changes in service delivery on the (i) referral rate, (ii) reasons for referral, (iii) demographic and clinical characteristics of the referrals and (iv) advice offered after assessment was examined with a retrospective design.
There was a significant decline in the number of referrals for each month across the three study phases exclusively accounted for by a decline between phase 2 and phase 3. The number of reasons for referral and management advice offered for social treatments per patient were greater in phase 1 compared to phase 2. The total number of management advice offered for medical treatments per patient was greater in phase 2 compared to phase 3. The cost of a specialist registrar attending a geriatric medicine ward round was more than offset by the associated decline in the number of referrals per month.
Although this study was not designed as a cost-effectiveness study, the results suggest that the liaison component has the potential to be cost-effective. There is a need for more formal clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness studies in liaison geriatric psychiatry.
在一项自然主义研究中,考察了服务提供方面的两项改变(医疗科室入院政策的变更以及为“仅咨询”联络老年精神病学服务引入正式联络环节)对相关联络老年精神病学服务的影响。主要原假设是转诊率不会受到服务提供方面任何一项改变的影响。
30个月的研究期根据服务提供方面的两项改变划分为三个阶段。采用回顾性设计,考察服务提供方面的两项改变对(i)转诊率、(ii)转诊原因、(iii)转诊患者的人口统计学和临床特征以及(iv)评估后提供的建议的影响。
在三个研究阶段中,每月转诊数量显著下降,这完全是由第2阶段和第3阶段之间的下降导致的。与第2阶段相比,第1阶段每位患者转诊原因的数量以及针对社会治疗提供的管理建议更多。与第3阶段相比,第2阶段每位患者针对药物治疗提供的管理建议总数更多。专科住院医师参加老年医学病房查房的成本被每月转诊数量的相应下降所抵消。
尽管本研究并非设计为成本效益研究,但结果表明联络环节有可能具有成本效益。在联络老年精神病学领域,需要进行更正式的临床有效性和成本效益研究。