Wiers-Jenssen J, Aasland O G
Norsk institutt for studier av forskning og utdanning, Oslo.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1999 Aug 20;119(19):2858-64.
A cohort of Norwegian medical students was followed through the pre-clinical part of medical school to study the development of specialty and leadership preferences. A questionnaire was sent to medical students immediately after they started their medical training in 1993, and again early in 1997 when the students had just started their clinical curriculum. 283 of 415 (68%) responded at both points in time. In order to investigate the relationship between various motivational variables and specialty and leadership preferences, five latent variables were identified through factor analysis: defensive, active, comprehensive, career-oriented and detached. Based on previous research in Norway, an index of prestige was constructed, where medical specialties and subspecialties were ranked according to the opinions of physicians and other health personnel. The intention was to explore the possible impact of prestige on specialty preferences. Career preferences were unstable on the individual but stable on the aggregate level. Interest in psychiatry, public health and laboratory medicine decreased during the first years of medical school, and high-prestige specialties became more appealing. Gender differences in career plans were distinct, stable and traditional. For future hospital physicians, leadership ambitions were much higher among men at both points in time. Our findings were that factors with bearing on choice of career are different for women and men, and preferences half-way through medical school are clearly related to such factors.
对一群挪威医学生从医学院校的临床前期开始进行跟踪研究,以了解他们专业和领导偏好的发展情况。1993年医学生刚开始医学培训时,以及1997年初学生刚开始临床课程时,分别向他们发放了调查问卷。415名学生中有283名(68%)在两个时间点都做出了回应。为了研究各种动机变量与专业和领导偏好之间的关系,通过因子分析确定了五个潜在变量:防御型、积极型、综合型、职业导向型和超脱型。根据挪威此前的研究,构建了一个声望指数,其中医学专业和亚专业是根据医生和其他卫生人员的意见进行排名的。目的是探讨声望对专业偏好可能产生的影响。职业偏好在个体层面不稳定,但在总体层面稳定。在医学院校学习的头几年里,对精神病学、公共卫生和检验医学的兴趣下降,而高声望专业变得更具吸引力。职业规划中的性别差异明显、稳定且传统。对于未来的医院医生来说,两个时间点上男性的领导抱负都要高得多。我们的研究结果是,影响职业选择的因素在男性和女性中有所不同,医学院校学习到一半时的偏好与这些因素明显相关。