Smith L C, Friedman S, Nevid J
Department of Psychiatry, State University of New York Health Science Center, Brooklyn 11203, USA.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1999 Sep;187(9):549-60. doi: 10.1097/00005053-199909000-00004.
Much attention has been paid to the study of panic disorder symptomatology among primarily European American populations. However, such research has not adequately generalized to include minority groups. The present study examined phenomenological differences between African American and European American patients with panic disorder with or without agoraphobia. African American (N = 48) and European American (N = 33) patients with panic disorder were assessed by structured interview and self-report questionnaires upon presentation to an anxiety disorders clinic for treatment. African Americans evidenced a higher rate of comorbid posttraumatic stress disorder (16% vs. 0%). European Americans reported having their initial panic attack at an earlier age than African Americans (21 vs. 29). In terms of discrete panic attack symptoms, African Americans reported more intense levels of numbing/tingling in extremities (4.3 vs. 2.5) as well as greater fear of dying (6.3 vs. 4) or going crazy (4.6 vs. 3) than European Americans. African Americans evidenced less satisfaction with social support (2.7 vs. 3.2), especially financial support (2.3 vs. 3.2), than European Americans. African Americans employed coping strategies such as counting one's blessings (1.9 vs. 1.4) and religiosity (1.9 vs. 1.2) more often than European Americans but evidenced less self blame (1.7 vs. 2). This study extends previous findings by showing that African Americans have a later age of onset as well as different coping strategies than European American patients with panic disorder.
人们主要对欧美人群中的惊恐障碍症状学进行了大量研究。然而,此类研究尚未充分推广到包括少数群体在内的范围。本研究调查了患有或未患有广场恐惧症的非裔美国人和欧美裔美国人惊恐障碍患者之间的现象学差异。患有惊恐障碍的非裔美国人(N = 48)和欧美裔美国人(N = 33)在前往焦虑症诊所接受治疗时,通过结构化访谈和自我报告问卷进行了评估。非裔美国人共病创伤后应激障碍的发生率更高(16%对0%)。欧美裔美国人报告其首次惊恐发作的年龄比非裔美国人更早(21岁对29岁)。在离散的惊恐发作症状方面,非裔美国人报告四肢麻木/刺痛的程度更强烈(4.3对2.5),以及比欧美裔美国人更害怕死亡(6.3对4)或发疯(4.6对3)。与欧美裔美国人相比,非裔美国人对社会支持的满意度较低(2.7对3.2),尤其是对经济支持的满意度(2.3对3.2)。非裔美国人比欧美裔美国人更常采用感恩(1.9对1.4)和宗教信仰(1.9对1.2)等应对策略,但自责程度较低(1.7对2)。本研究扩展了先前的研究结果,表明非裔美国人与患有惊恐障碍的欧美裔美国人相比,发病年龄较晚且应对策略不同。