Mattioli R C, Faye J A, Büscher P
International Trypanotolerance Centre, Banjul, Gambia.
Vet Parasitol. 1999 Sep 30;86(2):83-94. doi: 10.1016/s0304-4017(99)00117-x.
Susceptibility to Trypanosoma congolense, T. vivax challenge and cross species-superchallenges, and related effects on health and productivity were assessed in N'Dama cattle. Twenty-five N'Dama bulls aged 3-4 years and previously primed with trypanosome infections through natural tsetse exposure over more than one year were used. The experimental herd was divided in five groups each composed of five randomly selected animals. Group 1 was challenged with T. congolense, Group 2 with T. vivax, Group 3 was inoculated with T. congolense followed by a cross-superchallenge with T. vivax, Group 4 was inoculated with T. vivax followed by T. congolense cross-superchallenge. Animals in Group 5 were used as controls. Both T. vivax and T. congolense cross-superchallenges were carried out on Day 14 subsequent to respective initial T. congolense and T. vivax inoculations. All challenges were performed by intradermal needle inoculation of stocks of trypanosome bloodstream forms. In challenged animals (Group 1 to 4), parasitaemia profiles and packed red cell volumes (PCV) were measured for four months. Weight changes were recorded monthly and daily weight gain (DWG) computed. All cattle challenged with T. congolense became parasitaemic. Conversely, one animal in Group 2 and two in Group 3 never displayed patent T. vivax parasitaemia. Both in single (Group 1), initial (Group 3) and cross-superchallenged (Group 4) cattle higher percentage of positive blood samples and higher parasitaemia level were obtained following T. congolense than T. vivax inocula (Group 2, 3 and 4) (P<0.04 or greater). Overall the pre-challenge period, PCV values and DWGs were nearly identical in the five groups. Conversely, over the post-challenge period, cattle singly, initially and cross-superinoculated with T. congolense (Group 1, 3 and 4) displayed lower PCV values and DWGs in comparison with both control animals (Group 5) and with singly T. vivax challenged cattle (Group 2) (P<0.05 or greater). No difference in mean PCV levels and DWGs was found between animals in Group 2 and cattle in Group 5. It was concluded that trypanotolerant N'Dama cattle suffered more from T. congolense and mixed T. congolensel T. vivax infections, while pure T. vivax infection did not produce appreciable negative effects on their health and productivity. Therefore, considering that tsetse and trypanosomosis control campaigns are costly and are justified only when derived economic benefits exceed those of control, and also that an ample mosaic of farming systems exists in West Africa, species-specific trypanosome prevalence and relative impact should be assessed in various cattle populations and breeds differing in trypanosome susceptibility before advising any intervention. Moreover, virulence and related effects of T. congolense and T. vivax endemic stocks on health and productivity in local cattle populations should also be estimated in order to counsel appropriate economic protection measures against trypanosmosis, i.e. vector control and/or strategic use of trypanocidal drugs.
在恩达马牛中评估了对刚果锥虫、活跃锥虫攻击及跨物种超感染的易感性,以及对健康和生产力的相关影响。使用了25头3 - 4岁的恩达马公牛,这些公牛此前通过自然采采蝇叮咬感染锥虫超过一年。实验牛群分为五组,每组由五只随机挑选的动物组成。第1组用刚果锥虫攻击,第2组用活跃锥虫攻击,第3组先接种刚果锥虫,随后用活跃锥虫进行跨物种超感染,第4组先接种活跃锥虫,随后用刚果锥虫进行跨物种超感染。第5组动物作为对照。在分别首次接种刚果锥虫和活跃锥虫后的第14天,对活跃锥虫和刚果锥虫进行跨物种超感染。所有攻击均通过皮内注射锥虫血流形式的虫株进行。在受攻击的动物(第1组至第4组)中,测量了四个月的寄生虫血症谱和红细胞压积(PCV)。每月记录体重变化并计算日增重(DWG)。所有用刚果锥虫攻击的牛都出现了寄生虫血症。相反,第2组中有一头动物和第3组中有两头动物从未出现活跃锥虫的显性寄生虫血症。无论是单次(第1组)、初次(第3组)还是跨物种超感染(第4组)的牛,接种刚果锥虫后获得的阳性血样百分比和寄生虫血症水平均高于接种活跃锥虫后(第2组、第3组和第4组)(P<0.04或更高)。总体而言,在攻击前阶段,五组的PCV值和DWG几乎相同。相反,在攻击后阶段,与对照动物(第5组)和仅用活跃锥虫攻击的牛(第2组)相比,单次、初次和跨物种接种刚果锥虫的牛(第1组、第3组和第4组)的PCV值和DWG较低(P<0.05或更高)。第2组动物和第5组牛之间的平均PCV水平和DWG没有差异。得出的结论是,耐锥虫的恩达马牛受刚果锥虫以及刚果锥虫与活跃锥虫混合感染的影响更大,而单纯的活跃锥虫感染对其健康和生产力没有产生明显的负面影响。因此,考虑到采采蝇和锥虫病防治运动成本高昂,只有在获得的经济效益超过防治成本时才合理,而且西非存在多种农业系统,在建议任何干预措施之前,应在不同锥虫易感性的各种牛群和品种中评估特定物种的锥虫流行率和相对影响。此外,还应估计刚果锥虫和活跃锥虫地方流行株对当地牛群健康和生产力的毒力及相关影响,以便就防治锥虫病的适当经济保护措施提供建议,即病媒控制和/或杀锥虫药物的战略使用。