Iizuka N, Satoh T, Yamane M
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Tokyo Metropolitan Police Hospital.
Nihon Jibiinkoka Gakkai Kaiho. 1999 Sep;102(9):1028-35. doi: 10.3950/jibiinkoka.102.1028.
This report describes a new procedure for examining functional deafness with binaural sound stimulation. This new hearing test can estimate the genuine pure tone hearing threshold quantitatively at every frequency by using the ordinary audiometer. In the case of the nonorganic deafness, even if the hearing disorders are bilateral or hemilateral, we believe that measuring auditory threshold separately, causes the deterioration of the threshold. Therefore, this procedure is designed so that the subject may not be aware of testing the auditory acuity of each ear, and utilizes the response of the phantom sound image in the head by simultaneous binaural presentation of sound stimulation. Our strategy is based on the following facts. If the normal subject has the same pure tone threshold level in both ears, the phantom sound image is formed in the median plane of the head by the equal suprathreshold tone level presented simultaneously in each ear. In the case of a unilateral auditory disorder, the sound image is localized to the center of the head only when sound stimulation louder than the threshold level of affected ear is given to both ears at the same time. Simultaneous binaural sound stimulation at a lower level than the threshold of the affected ear forms a lateralized sound image to the unaffected ear in the head. For patients with bilaterally similar hearing loss, the sound image is not formed if the stimulation is less than the threshold level of the pure tone. The band noise in the phase of each frequency with 50 dB HL was given binaurally to 10 normal hearing subjects, and the localization of the sound image formation was examined. This experiment confirmed that around the occipital region of the median plane in all subjects. Furthermore, comparing the formation threshold of the median plane image with the pure tone auditory threshold, proved that there was no significant difference statistically in either value. As a next step, 15 patients with unilateral sensorineural deafness were examined with this technique and we knew that the median sound images would not be formed with stimulation less than the pure tone auditory threshold of the affected ear. For clinical application, patients were classified into two groups with unilateral (6) and bilateral (2) functional deafness, and examined. Midline sound images definitely were formed with the lower magnitude of sound than the pure tone threshold by hemilateral nonorganic deafness. The difference of the forming threshold of the median sound image and the average of pure tone hearing level of the affected ear were maximum 100 dB, minimum 35 dB, and mean 69.4 dB. Furthermore, the difference of the median image forming threshold and the average hearing level of the unaffected ear were maximum 35 dB, minimum 0 dB, and mean 15.4 dB. In bilateral disorders, the midline plane sound image was formed with the corresponding level of the pure tone value in one subject, though the other one was determined by the maneuver method because it did not form a midline sound image. In conclusion, this examination can be readily used to estimate the genuine hearing threshold of the functional deafness.
本报告描述了一种通过双耳声音刺激检查功能性耳聋的新方法。这种新的听力测试可以使用普通听力计在每个频率上定量估计真正的纯音听力阈值。对于非器质性耳聋,即使听力障碍是双侧或单侧的,我们认为分别测量听阈会导致阈值恶化。因此,该方法的设计使得受试者不会意识到正在测试每只耳朵的听力敏锐度,并通过同时双耳呈现声音刺激来利用头部中幻听声音图像的反应。我们的策略基于以下事实。如果正常受试者双耳的纯音阈值水平相同,则通过每只耳朵同时呈现的相等阈上音水平在头部的正中平面形成幻听声音图像。在单侧听觉障碍的情况下,只有当同时向双耳给予比患耳阈值水平更高的声音刺激时,声音图像才会定位在头部中心。在低于患耳阈值的较低水平上同时进行双耳声音刺激会在头部中向未受影响的耳朵形成侧向化的声音图像。对于双侧听力损失相似的患者,如果刺激低于纯音阈值水平,则不会形成声音图像。向10名听力正常的受试者双耳给予每个频率50 dB HL相位的带噪声音,并检查声音图像形成的定位。该实验证实,在所有受试者的正中平面枕部区域周围。此外,将正中平面图像的形成阈值与纯音听阈进行比较,证明这两个值在统计学上没有显著差异。下一步,用该技术检查了15名单侧感音神经性耳聋患者,我们发现当刺激低于患耳的纯音听阈时,不会形成正中声音图像。为了临床应用,将患者分为单侧(6例)和双侧(2例)功能性耳聋两组并进行检查。对于单侧非器质性耳聋,以低于纯音阈值的较低声音强度肯定会形成中线声音图像。正中声音图像的形成阈值与患耳纯音听力水平平均值的差异最大为100 dB,最小为35 dB,平均为69.4 dB。此外,正中图像形成阈值与未受影响耳朵平均听力水平的差异最大为