Allal A S, Monney M, Rosset A, Ozsahin M, Guillemin C
Division of Radiation Oncology, University Hospital of Geneva, Switzerland.
Strahlenther Onkol. 2000 Jan;176(1):28-31. doi: 10.1007/pl00002301.
Accelerated radiotherapy delivery has recently been shown to be effective in overcoming repopulation during fractionated radiotherapy. The therapeutic ratio may be particularly favorable for 5-week regimens. This study reports the feasibility and results of a particular accelerated schedule in Stage III to IV head and neck carcinomas used in a multicenter setting.
Seventy-four patients with Stage III (26 patients) or IV (48 patients) head and neck carcinomas were treated with a 5-week accelerated schedule (69.6 to 69.8 Gy in 41 to 40 fractions over a period of 35 to 36 days). Treatment began with 20 Gy in 10 daily fractions to initial involved sites, followed by bi-fractionated radiotherapy (2 x 1.6 Gy to 1.66 Gy/day) to a larger head and neck volume. Thirty-six (49%) patients received induction chemotherapy (median 3 cycles, range 1 to 4 cycles).
Grade 3 or 4 (RTOG) confluent mucositis was observed in 57 patients (77%) and Grade 3 dysphagia in 33 patients (44%). Grade 3 or 4 (RTOG-EORTC) late complications were scored in 10.5% of cases. The 5-year actuarial locoregional control rate was 56% (95% CI: 42 to 71). The 5-year overall actuarial survival was 32% (95% CI: 18 to 46). Induction chemotherapy was not associated with a more favorable outcome.
This study demonstrates the feasibility of this schedule in a multicenter setting. The oncologic results appear similar to those obtained by other accelerated regimens, while the rate of late complications seems acceptable. Five-week accelerated regimens warrant further evaluation, particularly in conjunction with concomitant chemotherapy, in the framework of prospective trials.
最近研究表明,在分次放疗期间,加速放疗方案在克服肿瘤再增殖方面是有效的。对于5周的放疗方案,治疗增益比可能特别有利。本研究报告了在多中心环境下,针对III期至IV期头颈癌采用的一种特定加速放疗方案的可行性和结果。
74例III期(26例)或IV期(48例)头颈癌患者接受了为期5周的加速放疗方案(在35至36天内分41至40次给予69.6至69.8 Gy)。治疗开始时,对初始受累部位每天分10次给予20 Gy,随后对更大的头颈区域进行双分次放疗(每天2次,每次1.6 Gy至1.66 Gy)。36例(49%)患者接受了诱导化疗(中位3个周期,范围1至4个周期)。
57例患者(77%)出现3级或4级(RTOG)融合性黏膜炎,33例患者(44%)出现3级吞咽困难。10.5%的病例出现3级或4级(RTOG-EORTC)晚期并发症。5年精算局部区域控制率为56%(95%CI:42至71)。5年总精算生存率为32%(95%CI:18至46)。诱导化疗与更优的预后无关。
本研究证明了该方案在多中心环境下的可行性。肿瘤学结果似乎与其他加速放疗方案相似,而晚期并发症发生率似乎可以接受。5周加速放疗方案值得进一步评估,尤其是在前瞻性试验框架内与同步化疗联合使用时。