Malone S, Donker R, Broader M, Dahrouge S, Szanto J, Gerig L, Bociek G, Crook J
Department of Radiation Oncology, Ottawa Regional Cancer Centre, Ontario, Canada.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2000 Jan 1;46(1):89-93. doi: 10.1016/s0360-3016(99)00425-3.
Retrograde urethrography is commonly used to define the prostate apex at simulation. This study evaluated the hypothesis that urethrography causes prostate displacement, resulting in an error in treatment planning.
Forty-five patients with carcinoma of the prostate were evaluated. Gold seeds were placed in the apex, posterior wall, and base of the gland. In the first 20 patients, the position of the seed-defined apex was compared at simulation (with urethrogram) and on day 1 of treatment (without urethrogram). In the second cohort of 25 patients, the effects of urethrography on prostate position were evaluated directly at simulation by comparing the position of apex pre- and post-urethrography. An analysis was performed to estimate the possible impact of urethrogram-induced prostate motion on target coverage.
The mean superior displacement in the first and second cohort was 5.2 mm and 6.8 mm, respectively (combined mean shift 6.1 mm). With a 10-mm field margin below the tip of the urethrogram cone, 56% of patients in this study would have inadequate planning target volume (PTV) coverage.
Retrograde urethrography causes a significant superior shift of the prostate. Strict reliance on urethrography in determining the inferior field margin could result in inadequate treatment.
逆行尿道造影常用于在模拟定位时确定前列腺尖部。本研究评估了尿道造影导致前列腺移位从而在治疗计划中产生误差这一假说。
对45例前列腺癌患者进行评估。在腺体的尖部、后壁和底部植入金籽。在前20例患者中,比较了模拟定位时(行尿道造影)和治疗第1天(未行尿道造影)金籽确定的尖部位置。在第二组25例患者中,通过比较尿道造影前后尖部的位置,在模拟定位时直接评估尿道造影对前列腺位置的影响。进行分析以估计尿道造影引起的前列腺运动对靶区覆盖的可能影响。
第一组和第二组的平均向上移位分别为5.2 mm和6.8 mm(联合平均移位6.1 mm)。若在尿道造影锥尖下方设置10 mm的边界,本研究中56%的患者计划靶区(PTV)覆盖不足。
逆行尿道造影会导致前列腺显著向上移位。在确定下边界时严格依赖尿道造影可能导致治疗不足。