Ebraheim N A, Elgafy H, Sabry F F, Freih M, Abou-Chakra I S
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Medical College of Ohio, Toledo 43614, USA.
Foot Ankle Int. 2000 Feb;21(2):105-13. doi: 10.1177/107110070002100203.
The charts and radiographs of 99 patients with 106 intraarticular fractures of the calcaneus were retrospectively reviewed. There were 75 men and 24 women. The average age was forty-two (range, 17 to 81). Fifty-seven of the fractures were left and 49 were right. The mechanism of injury was a fall from a height in 69 patients and motor vehicle accident in 30 patients. According to Sanders classification, seventy-one cases (67%) had type II fractures, 25 cases (23.6%) had type III, and ten cases (9.4%) had type IV. All the patients had operative management through a limited sinus tarsi approach with minimal fixation of the fracture with one or several pins. One of the pins was usually applied from the talus to the calcaneus through the fracture after reduction of the posterior facet. Nine cases (8.5%) developed postoperative infection, four cases (3.8%) had superficial wound infection, four cases (3.8%) had pin tract infection and one case (0.9%) had osteomylitis. Our follow-up at an average of 29 months (range, 12 to 84 months) showed that the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society, Ankle-Hindfoot Score for the all group was 77.6 (range, 31-91). Forty-one fractures (38.8%) were graded excellent, 39 fractures (36.7%) good, 14 fractures (13.2%) fair, and 12 fractures (11.3%) were failures. Although radiological degenerative changes in the subtalar joint were seen in 41 cases (38.7%), only six cases (5.6%) required subsequent subtalar fusion. The authors conclude that the operative method used in the current study which followed the principle of minimal soft tissue damage and minimal internal fixation may be a good option for management of calcaneus fractures.
回顾性分析99例患者106例跟骨关节内骨折的图表和X线片。其中男性75例,女性24例。平均年龄42岁(范围17至81岁)。57例骨折位于左侧,49例位于右侧。损伤机制为69例高处坠落伤和30例机动车事故伤。根据Sanders分类,71例(67%)为Ⅱ型骨折,25例(23.6%)为Ⅲ型,10例(9.4%)为Ⅳ型。所有患者均采用有限距下关节入路手术治疗,用一根或几根钢针进行骨折的最小化固定。通常在复位后关节面后,通过骨折部位从距骨向跟骨打入一根钢针。9例(8.5%)发生术后感染,4例(3.8%)为表浅伤口感染,4例(3.8%)为针道感染,1例(0.9%)为骨髓炎。我们平均随访29个月(范围12至84个月),结果显示全组美国矫形足踝协会踝-后足评分为77.6(范围31 - 91)。41例骨折(38.8%)评定为优,39例(36.7%)为良,14例(13.2%)为可,12例(11.3%)治疗失败。虽然41例(38.7%)距下关节出现影像学退变改变,但仅6例(5.6%)需要二期距下关节融合。作者得出结论,本研究中采用的遵循软组织损伤最小化和内固定最小化原则的手术方法可能是治疗跟骨骨折的一个良好选择。