Hill D A, Weiss N S, LaCroix A Z
Department of Epidemiology, University of Washington, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, USA.
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2000 Feb;182(2):270-6. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9378(00)70210-9.
In randomized trials a higher proportion of women prescribed continuous combined hormone replacement therapy complete the full course of treatment compared with those prescribed sequential therapy. We sought to determine adherence to hormone therapy in a less-selected population.
Women enrolled in a prepaid health plan participated in a telephone interview 12 to 15 months after newly initiating use of hormone replacement therapy. The interview elicited information on whether the women were still taking the hormones as first prescribed and reasons for switching or discontinuation. A computerized pharmacy database was used to determine initial doses, prescription renewal, and dates of switching or discontinuation.
The proportion continuing the originally prescribed hormone regimen at 1 year was higher among continuous combined therapy users (68.9%, 62/90) than among sequential therapy users (54.4%, 62/114). Women who initiated continuous combined therapy were less likely to have switched regimens (10.0%) than were sequential users (20.2%; relative risk, 0.5; 95% confidence interval, 0.2-1.0) but only somewhat less likely to have discontinued use (21.2% vs 25.4%; relative risk, 0.7; 95% confidence interval, 0.4-1.3). Examined as a whole, women prescribed continuous combined therapy were less likely than those prescribed sequential therapy to quit or switch during the first year (relative risk, 0.6; 95% confidence interval, 0.4-1.0).
Although adherence was higher among women prescribed continuous combined hormone replacement therapy than sequential therapy, the high level of nonadherence in both groups suggests room for improvement of menopausal therapies so that women find them acceptable for sustained use.
在随机试验中,与接受序贯疗法的女性相比,接受连续联合激素替代疗法的女性完成整个疗程治疗的比例更高。我们试图确定在一个选择标准没那么严格的人群中激素治疗的依从性情况。
参加预付健康计划的女性在开始新的激素替代疗法使用12至15个月后接受电话访谈。访谈获取了这些女性是否仍按首次处方服用激素以及换药或停药原因的信息。使用计算机化药房数据库来确定初始剂量、处方续期以及换药或停药日期。
连续联合疗法使用者在1年时继续使用最初规定激素方案的比例(68.9%,62/90)高于序贯疗法使用者(54.4%,62/114)。开始连续联合疗法的女性更换治疗方案的可能性(10.0%)低于序贯疗法使用者(20.2%;相对风险,0.5;95%置信区间,0.2 - 1.0),但停药可能性仅略低(21.2%对25.4%;相对风险,0.7;95%置信区间,0.4 - 1.3)。总体来看,接受连续联合疗法的女性在第一年退出或换药的可能性低于接受序贯疗法的女性(相对风险,0.6;95%置信区间,0.4 - 1.0)。
尽管接受连续联合激素替代疗法的女性依从性高于序贯疗法,但两组的高不依从率表明更年期治疗仍有改进空间,以便女性能够接受并持续使用这些疗法。