Johnson J R, Clabots C
VA Medical Center and Department of Medicine, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
Clin Diagn Lab Immunol. 2000 Mar;7(2):258-64. doi: 10.1128/CDLI.7.2.258-264.2000.
Modified thermal cycling conditions were explored in an effort to improve the reproducibility and resolving power of repetitive-element PCR (rep-PCR) fingerprinting. Assay performance was rigorously evaluated under standard and modified cycling conditions, using as a test set 12 strains putatively representing 12 serovars of Salmonella enterica. For all three fingerprint types (ERIC2, BOXA1R, and composite fingerprints), the use of extremely elevated annealing temperatures plus an initial "touchdown" cycling routine yielded significant improvements in day-to-day reproducibility and discriminating power despite the somewhat sparser appearance of the fingerprints. Modified cycling conditions markedly reduced the variability of fingerprints between cyclers, allowing fingerprints from different cyclers to be analyzed together without the degradation of assay performance that occurred with between-cycler analyses under standard cycling conditions. With modified cycling, composite fingerprints exhibited the lowest reproducibility but the highest net discriminating power of the three fingerprint types. rep-PCR fingerprints led to the discovery of a serotyping error involving one of the 12 test strains. These data demonstrate that modified cycling regimens that incorporate elevated annealing temperatures (with or without an initial touchdown routine) may markedly improve the performance of rep-PCR fingerprinting as a bacterial typing tool.
为提高重复元件聚合酶链反应(rep-PCR)指纹图谱的重现性和分辨能力,对热循环条件进行了优化。在标准和优化的循环条件下,使用12株推测代表肠炎沙门氏菌12个血清型的菌株作为测试集,对检测性能进行了严格评估。对于所有三种指纹类型(ERIC2、BOXA1R和复合指纹),尽管指纹外观略显稀疏,但使用极高的退火温度加上初始的“降落”循环程序,可显著提高日常重现性和鉴别能力。优化的循环条件显著降低了不同循环仪之间指纹的变异性,使得来自不同循环仪的指纹能够一起分析,而不会像在标准循环条件下进行循环仪间分析那样导致检测性能下降。采用优化循环时,复合指纹在三种指纹类型中重现性最低,但净鉴别能力最高。rep-PCR指纹图谱导致发现了12株测试菌株中的一株存在血清型鉴定错误。这些数据表明,采用升高退火温度(有或没有初始降落程序)的优化循环方案,可显著提高rep-PCR指纹图谱作为细菌分型工具的性能。