Hilgetag C C, Grant S
Department of Psychology, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2000 Jan 29;355(1393):7-20. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2000.0546.
In many studies of the mammalian brain, subjective assessments of connectivity patterns and connection strengths have been used to subdivide the cortex into separate but linked areas and to make deductions about the flow of information through the cortical network. Here we describe the results of applying statistical analyses to quantitative corticocortical connection data, and the conclusions that can be drawn from such quantitative approaches. Injections of the tracer WGA-HRP were made into different visual areas either side of the middle suprasylvian sulcus (MSS) in 11 adult cats. Retrogradely labelled cells produced by these injections were counted in selected coronal sections taken at regularly spaced intervals (1 mm) through the entire visual cortex, and their cumulative sums and relative proportions in each of 16 recognized visual cortical areas were computed. The surface dimensions of these areas were measured in each cat, from contour lines made on enlarged drawings of the same sections. A total of 116,149 labelled neurons were assigned to all visual cortical areas in the 11 cats, with 5212 others excluded because of their uncertain location. The distribution of relative connection strengths, that is, the percentage of labelled cells per cortical area, was evaluated using non-parametric cluster analyses and Monte Carlo simulation, and relationships between connection strength and area size were examined by linear regression. The absolute size of each visual cortical area was uniform across individual cats, whereas the strengths of connections between the same area pairs were extremely variable for injections in different animals. The overall distribution of labelling strengths for corticocortical connections was continuous and monotonic, rather than inherently clustered, with the highest frequencies presented by the absent (zero density) and the very-low-density connections. These two categories could not, on analytical grounds, be separated from each other. Thus it seems that any subjective description of corticocortical connectivity strengths by ordinal classes (such as 'absent', 'weak', 'moderate' or 'strong') imposes a categorization on the data, rather than recognizes a structure inherent in the data themselves. Despite the great variability of connections, similarities in the distribution profiles for the relative strengths of labelled cells in all areas could be used to identify clusters of different injection sites in the MSS. This supported the conclusion that there are four connectionally distinct subdivisions of this cortex, corresponding to areas 21a, PMLS and AMLS (in the medial bank) and to area PLLS (in the lateral bank). Even for tracer deposits in the same cortical subdivision, however, the strength of connections projecting to the site from other cortical areas varied greatly across injection in different individual animals. We further demonstrated that, on average, the strength of connections originating from any given cortical area was positively and linearly correlated with the size of its surface dimensions. When analysed by specific injection site location, however, this relationship was shown to hold for the individual connections to the medial bank MSS areas, but not for connections leading to the lateral bank area. The data suggest that connectivity of the cat's visual cortex possesses a number of uniform global features, which are locally organized in such a way as to give each cortical area unique characteristics.
在许多关于哺乳动物大脑的研究中,人们通过对连接模式和连接强度进行主观评估,将皮层划分为不同但相互关联的区域,并推断信息在皮层网络中的流动情况。在此,我们描述了将统计分析应用于定量皮质 - 皮质连接数据的结果,以及可从这些定量方法得出的结论。在11只成年猫的大脑中,将示踪剂WGA - HRP注射到中颞上沟(MSS)两侧的不同视觉区域。通过在整个视觉皮层以规则间隔(1毫米)获取的选定冠状切片中,对这些注射产生的逆行标记细胞进行计数,并计算其在16个公认的视觉皮层区域中每个区域的累积总和及相对比例。在每只猫中,从相同切片的放大图上绘制的轮廓线测量这些区域的表面尺寸。11只猫的所有视觉皮层区域共分配了116,149个标记神经元,另有5212个因位置不确定而被排除。使用非参数聚类分析和蒙特卡罗模拟评估相对连接强度的分布,即每个皮层区域标记细胞的百分比,并通过线性回归检查连接强度与区域大小之间的关系。每个视觉皮层区域的绝对大小在不同个体猫之间是一致的,而对于不同动物的注射,相同区域对之间的连接强度变化极大。皮质 - 皮质连接的标记强度总体分布是连续且单调的,而非固有聚类,频率最高的是无连接(零密度)和极低密度连接。基于分析理由,这两类无法相互分离。因此,似乎通过序数类别(如“无”“弱”“中等”或“强”)对皮质 - 皮质连接强度进行的任何主观描述都是对数据进行分类,而不是识别数据本身固有的结构。尽管连接存在很大变异性,但所有区域中标记细胞相对强度分布曲线的相似性可用于识别MSS中不同注射部位的聚类。这支持了这样的结论,即该皮层有四个连接上不同的细分区域,分别对应于21a区、PMLS和AMLS(在内侧脑回)以及PLLS区(在外侧脑回)。然而,即使对于同一皮质细分区域内的示踪剂沉积,从其他皮质区域投射到该部位的连接强度在不同个体动物的注射中也有很大差异。我们进一步证明,平均而言,源自任何给定皮质区域的连接强度与其表面尺寸大小呈正线性相关。然而,按特定注射部位位置分析时,这种关系仅适用于与内侧脑回MSS区域的单个连接,而不适用于通向外侧脑回区域的连接。数据表明,猫视觉皮层的连接性具有许多统一的全局特征,这些特征在局部以赋予每个皮层区域独特特性的方式进行组织。