Staibano S, Lo Muzio L, Mezza E, Argenziano G, Tornillo L, Pannone G, De Rosa G
Department of Biomorphological and Functional Sciences, Pathology Section, Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, University "Federico II", Naples, Italy.
Oral Oncol. 1999 Nov;35(6):541-7. doi: 10.1016/s1368-8375(99)00028-7.
Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) is the most common type of human cancer, often locally invasive, and following a benign clinical course. However, a proportion of BCCs do recur after treatment, causing extensive local tissue destruction, seldom metastasizing. Morphological methods to unequivocally distinguish the aggressive forms of these tumors (BCC2) from the ordinary ones (BCC1) have so far been lacking. Apoptosis, or programmed cell death, is thought to be important for the death of tumor cells in various stages of carcinogenesis. We analyzed the extent of apoptosis in BCCs of head and neck in a morphological, morphometric, and electron-microscopic study, to estabilish on a retrospective basis, the relative frequency of recurrence of tumors showing different apoptotic rates. We found that BCC1 showed lower apoptotic index (AI) than BCC2 [BCC1: AI from 2.03 to 10.45% (mean value: 5.98%) BCC2: AI from 21. 91 up to 43.82% (mean value: 39.82%)]. The morphometric analysis of both BCC1 and BCC2 revealed significant differences between the values concerning nuclear area, length, perimeter, and roundness of the apoptotic cells with respect to the 'viable' neoplastic cells. Electron-microscopy confirmed that the features of morphological apoptotic cells were characteristic of programmed cell death. We hypothesized that low apoptotic rates in BCC1 could be indicative of a good prognosis. In fact, this corresponded to an 'expansive' but not still invasive neoplastic state. In this phase, however, the tumor cells may constitute the target for genetic changes triggered by enviromental physical or chemical mutagenic agents, such as UV rays. BCC2, then, could be the result of newly selected mutated neoplastic cellular clones, with more aggressive biological behavior. The high apoptotic level found in BCC2 could thus be used as an indirect alarm signal from pathologists. This hypothesis seems to be supported by most of the current data in the literature and by the clinical outcome of BCC2 of our series. In our opinion, routine evaluation of apoptosis in BCCs could be proposed to facilitate their sub-classification, contributing toward the evaluation of the prospective outcome of the individual patients.
基底细胞癌(BCC)是人类最常见的癌症类型,通常呈局部浸润性生长,临床过程为良性。然而,一部分BCC在治疗后确实会复发,导致广泛的局部组织破坏,很少发生转移。到目前为止,还缺乏明确区分这些肿瘤的侵袭性形式(BCC2)与普通形式(BCC1)的形态学方法。细胞凋亡,即程序性细胞死亡,被认为在致癌作用的各个阶段对肿瘤细胞的死亡很重要。我们通过形态学、形态计量学和电子显微镜研究分析了头颈部BCC的凋亡程度,以回顾性地确定显示不同凋亡率的肿瘤的相对复发频率。我们发现BCC1的凋亡指数(AI)低于BCC2 [BCC1:AI为2.03%至10.45%(平均值:5.98%);BCC2:AI为21.91%至43.82%(平均值:39.82%)]。对BCC1和BCC2的形态计量分析显示,凋亡细胞与“存活”肿瘤细胞在核面积、长度、周长和圆度方面的值存在显著差异。电子显微镜证实,形态学凋亡细胞的特征是程序性细胞死亡的特征。我们假设BCC1中低凋亡率可能预示着良好的预后。事实上,这对应于一种“扩展性”但尚未侵袭性的肿瘤状态。然而,在此阶段,肿瘤细胞可能成为环境物理或化学诱变剂(如紫外线)引发的基因变化的靶点。那么,BCC2可能是新选择的具有更具侵袭性生物学行为的突变肿瘤细胞克隆的结果。因此,在BCC2中发现的高凋亡水平可作为病理学家的间接警示信号。这一假设似乎得到了文献中大多数现有数据以及我们系列中BCC2临床结果的支持。我们认为,可以建议对头颈部BCC的凋亡进行常规评估,以促进其亚分类,有助于评估个体患者的预期结果。