Bianchi F, Calzolari E, Ciulli L, Cordier S, Gualandi F, Pierini A, Mossey P
Istituto di Fisiologia Clinica del CNR, Pisa.
Epidemiol Prev. 2000 Jan-Feb;24(1):21-7.
The combined birth prevalence of cleft palate [CP] and cleft lip with or without cleft palate [CL(P)] in Europe is approximately one in 700 with characteristic regional variations. Orofacial clefting (OC) is therefore now one of the most frequent congenital anomalies, with a higher birth prevalence that Down's Syndrome or Neural Tube defects, but still lower than cardiovascular malformation. Babies with OC require a multidisciplinary medical approach, surgery and rehabilitative treatments over time. This means an important effort in terms of social organization as well as economical costs for the health care system. In Italy, the health care costs for approximately 800 children born with orofacial clefting per year has been estimated at around 150 billion Lire (80 million Euros). The etiology of OC is complex and heterogeneous both for isolated and associated defects; causes linked to environment, genetics and gene-environment interaction are known, although there is still a lot to do, especially in clarifying the role of genetics in producing susceptibility to the environment. Four categories of genes for which there are results suggestive of a genetic susceptibility to OCs are: 1) genes expressed in a particular area of the embryo or in a particular period of the palatine arch development, such as the transforming growth factors alpha and beta (TGF alpha, TGF beta 2, TGF beta 3); 2) genes having biological activities linked to the OC's pathogenesis without direct involvement (e.g. the retinoic acid receptor (RARA), the methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase receptor (MTHFR) and the folic acid receptor (FOLR1); 3) genes or locus identified in experimental animals as the homeotic genes MSX-1 and MSX-2; 4) genes involved in the interaction with the xenobiotics metabolism as those in P-450 cytochrome system. Several environmental factors have been implicated in the OC etiology; among those, the folic acid supplementation during the periconceptional period that was found effective in the prevention of neural tube defects. In fact, folic acid deficiency may be responsible for different malformations through a common mechanism that interferes with the embryonic development, depending on the maternal or embryo genotype. Further investigation is required to study in depth how the genotype would modify the role of environmental factors like folic acid. Well-designed and conducted epidemiological studies seem to be able to give worthwhile information. Studies carried out in Europe on these issues are a few, particularly those on gene-environment interaction. Recent results obtained in molecular biology and the availability of wealth of data can allow to perform ad hoc investigations, being important not only for the basic research but also for their public health implications. For this objective a specific scientific network at the European level has been set by the European Science Foundation (ESF), whose first step will be to establish consistent case ascertainment and data collection across Europe and to develop standardized protocols and methods of analysis. It is hoped that in the longer term such multicentre collaborative research will enable combined analysis and lead to the identification of genetic susceptibility to certain environmental factors, including nutrition. Such studies would inform the current debate about the efficacy of folic acid and other nutritional factors in prevention of disease in the developing embryo. Subsequent public health measures targeted according to risk might reduce the prevalence of disorders such as orofacial clefting.
在欧洲,腭裂(CP)以及唇裂伴或不伴腭裂(CL(P))的合并出生患病率约为700分之一,且存在明显的地区差异。因此,口面部裂(OC)是最常见的先天性畸形之一,其出生患病率高于唐氏综合征或神经管缺陷,但仍低于心血管畸形。患有OC的婴儿需要长期的多学科医疗方法、手术及康复治疗。这意味着在社会组织以及医疗保健系统的经济成本方面都需要付出巨大努力。在意大利,据估计每年约800名患有口面部裂的儿童的医疗保健费用约为1500亿里拉(8000万欧元)。OC的病因对于孤立性缺陷和关联性缺陷而言都很复杂且具有异质性;已知与环境、遗传以及基因 - 环境相互作用相关的病因,不过仍有许多工作要做,尤其是在阐明遗传因素在产生对环境易感性方面的作用。有四类基因的研究结果提示对OC存在遗传易感性:1)在胚胎特定区域或腭弓发育特定时期表达的基因,如转化生长因子α和β(TGFα、TGFβ2、TGFβ3);2)具有与OC发病机制相关的生物学活性但无直接参与的基因(例如视黄酸受体(RARA)、亚甲基四氢叶酸还原酶受体(MTHFR)和叶酸受体(FOLR1));3)在实验动物中被鉴定为同源异型基因的MSX - 1和MSX - 2基因或基因座;4)参与与外源性物质代谢相互作用的基因,如细胞色素P - 450系统中的基因。几种环境因素与OC病因有关;其中,孕期补充叶酸被发现对预防神经管缺陷有效。事实上,叶酸缺乏可能通过干扰胚胎发育的共同机制导致不同畸形,这取决于母体或胚胎基因型。需要进一步研究以深入了解基因型如何改变叶酸等环境因素的作用。精心设计和实施的流行病学研究似乎能够提供有价值的信息。在欧洲针对这些问题开展的研究较少,特别是关于基因 - 环境相互作用的研究。分子生物学领域最近取得的成果以及丰富数据的可得性使得开展专项研究成为可能,这不仅对基础研究很重要,对其公共卫生意义也很重要。为实现这一目标,欧洲科学基金会(ESF)在欧洲层面设立了一个特定的科学网络,其第一步将是在全欧洲建立一致的病例确诊和数据收集,并制定标准化的方案和分析方法。希望从长远来看,这种多中心合作研究能够进行综合分析,并导致识别出对某些环境因素(包括营养)的遗传易感性。此类研究将为当前关于叶酸和其他营养因素在预防发育中胚胎疾病方面功效的辩论提供信息。随后根据风险制定的公共卫生措施可能会降低口面部裂等疾病的患病率。