White S, O'Neill D
Centre for Mobility Enhancement, Adelaide and Meath Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Gerontology. 2000 May-Jun;46(3):146-52. doi: 10.1159/000022150.
The number of older drivers is increasing rapidly in the developed world. Many states of the European Union (EU) have initiated legislation to screen older drivers for age-related disease, despite evidence that screening may be harmful or have no positive effect.
We reviewed the current situation in the EU by sending a questionnaire to the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency in each member state.
All fifteen countries replied. Regular medical screening occurs in ten. European Council Directive 91/439/EEC forms the basis for national guidelines on medical fitness to drive, but these are not specific for age-related illness, and interpretation of the directive varies between countries. Specific guidelines are not available in all countries for the age-related conditions of dementia, stroke, and Parkinson's disease. In nine countries a medical colleague is available for consultation in difficult cases. Drivers are required to report illness to the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency only in the United Kingdom. In six countries, there is mandatory reporting by physicians of conditions which may pose a risk to driving.
There is considerable heterogeneity within the EU on the processes of older driver screening. This diversity may facilitate research into the effect of different policies on safe mobility of older people. If changes in the screening process are considered, further knowledge is needed on issues such as older driver exposure and valid measures of safe mobility for the EU. More evidence-based research is required to help policy makers frame future guidelines and legislation, so as to promote safe mobility of older people.
在发达国家,老年驾驶员的数量正在迅速增加。尽管有证据表明筛查可能有害或没有积极效果,但欧盟的许多成员国已启动立法,对老年驾驶员进行与年龄相关疾病的筛查。
我们向每个成员国的驾驶员和车辆许可机构发送了一份调查问卷,以审查欧盟的当前情况。
所有15个国家都进行了回复。有10个国家进行定期医学筛查。欧洲理事会指令91/439/EEC构成了国家驾驶医学适宜性指南的基础,但这些指南并非专门针对与年龄相关的疾病,并且各国对该指令的解释各不相同。并非所有国家都有针对痴呆症、中风和帕金森病等与年龄相关疾病的具体指南。在9个国家,在疑难病例中有医学同事可供咨询。只有在英国,驾驶员才被要求向驾驶员和车辆许可机构报告疾病。在6个国家,医生必须报告可能对驾驶构成风险的情况。
欧盟内部在老年驾驶员筛查流程方面存在很大差异。这种多样性可能有助于研究不同政策对老年人安全出行的影响。如果考虑对筛查流程进行变革,就需要在老年驾驶员暴露情况以及欧盟安全出行的有效衡量标准等问题上获取更多知识。需要开展更多基于证据的研究,以帮助政策制定者制定未来的指南和立法,从而促进老年人的安全出行。