Chao C, Hoffman J P, Ross E A, Torosian M H, Eisenberg B L
Department of Surgery, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19111, USA.
Am Surg. 2000 Apr;66(4):378-85; discussion 386.
Only a minority of patients with a diagnosis of pancreatic adenocarcinoma (PA) have disease amenable to curative resection. Between April 1987 and March 1999, 40 patients with pancreatic adenocarcinoma deemed unresectable at exploration at other institutions were considered for neoadjuvant treatments and then re-evaluated for possible re-exploration. We retrospectively compared the clinical outcomes, including overall survival (OS), among three groups: Group A, 22 previously unresectable patients who were subsequently successfully resected, 20 after induction therapy; Group B, 31 patients who received preoperative chemoradiotherapy before their only operation; and Group C, 33 patients who were primarily resected, 27 of whom were then treated with adjuvant therapy. Of those resectable from Group A, 5 required portal venorrhaphy and 3 had hepatic artery reconstruction. Eighteen of the 40 patients were unresectable because of progression of disease with a mean OS of 8 months; 12 were assessed at second laparotomy; 6 were excluded from second operation on the basis of preoperative imaging studies. Kaplan-Meier curves showed no differences in OS among the three groups: OS in Group A was 34 months; Group B, 21; and Group C, 13 (P = 0.15). Margin status was comparable in all three groups (P = 0.52). As expected, nodal positivity was greatest in Group C (P = 0.001). There were no operative mortalities in Group A, and the morbidity rate was comparable with that of Groups B and C. Upon re-evaluation, many tumors (54%) previously deemed "unresectable" were surgically extirpated for cure with a median survival comparable with that of patients who did not undergo previous exploration.
仅少数诊断为胰腺腺癌(PA)的患者其疾病适合进行根治性切除。在1987年4月至1999年3月期间,40例在其他机构探查时被认为无法切除的胰腺腺癌患者接受了新辅助治疗,然后重新评估是否可能再次探查。我们回顾性比较了三组患者的临床结局,包括总生存期(OS):A组,22例先前无法切除但随后成功切除的患者,其中20例在诱导治疗后切除;B组,31例在仅有的一次手术前接受术前放化疗的患者;C组,33例接受一期切除的患者,其中27例随后接受辅助治疗。A组中可切除的患者里,5例需要门静脉修补,3例进行了肝动脉重建。40例患者中有18例因疾病进展而无法切除,其平均总生存期为8个月;12例接受了二次剖腹探查;6例根据术前影像学检查被排除在二次手术之外。Kaplan-Meier曲线显示三组患者的总生存期无差异:A组的总生存期为34个月;B组为21个月;C组为13个月(P = 0.15)。三组的切缘状态相当(P = 0.52)。正如预期的那样,C组的淋巴结阳性率最高(P = 0.001)。A组无手术死亡病例,其发病率与B组和C组相当。重新评估时,许多先前被认为“无法切除”的肿瘤(54%)通过手术切除得以治愈,其生存期与未接受先前探查的患者相当。