Minto C F, Schnider T W, Short T G, Gregg K M, Gentilini A, Shafer S L
Palo Alto VA Health Care System, Palo Alto, California, USA.
Anesthesiology. 2000 Jun;92(6):1603-16. doi: 10.1097/00000542-200006000-00017.
Anesthetic drug interactions traditionally have been characterized using isobolographic analysis or multiple logistic regression. Both approaches have significant limitations. The authors propose a model based on response-surface methodology. This model can characterize the entire dose-response relation between combinations of anesthetic drugs and is mathematically consistent with models of the concentration-response relation of single drugs.
The authors defined a parameter, theta, that describes the concentration ratio of two potentially interacting drugs. The classic sigmoid Emax model was extended by making the model parameters dependent on theta. A computer program was used to estimate response surfaces for the hypnotic interaction between midazolam, propofol, and alfentanil, based on previously published data. The predicted time course of effect was simulated after maximally synergistic bolus dose combinations.
The parameters of the response surface were identifiable. With the test data, each of the paired combinations showed significant synergy. Computer simulations based on interactions at the effect site predicted that the maximally synergistic three-drug combination tripled the duration of effect compared with propofol alone.
Response surfaces can describe anesthetic interactions, even those between agonists, partial agonists, competitive antagonists, and inverse agonists. Application of response-surface methodology permits characterization of the full concentration-response relation and therefore can be used to develop practical guidelines for optimal drug dosing.
传统上,麻醉药物相互作用是通过等效应线分析或多元逻辑回归来表征的。这两种方法都有显著局限性。作者提出了一种基于响应面方法的模型。该模型可以表征麻醉药物组合之间的整个剂量-反应关系,并且在数学上与单一药物的浓度-反应关系模型一致。
作者定义了一个参数θ,用于描述两种可能相互作用药物的浓度比。通过使模型参数依赖于θ,对经典的S形Emax模型进行了扩展。基于先前发表的数据,使用计算机程序来估计咪达唑仑、丙泊酚和阿芬太尼之间催眠相互作用的响应面。在最大协同推注剂量组合后,模拟了效应的预测时间进程。
响应面的参数是可识别的。对于测试数据,每对组合均显示出显著的协同作用。基于效应部位相互作用的计算机模拟预测,与单独使用丙泊酚相比,最大协同三药组合使效应持续时间增加了两倍。
响应面可以描述麻醉药物相互作用,即使是激动剂、部分激动剂、竞争性拮抗剂和反向激动剂之间的相互作用。应用响应面方法可以表征完整的浓度-反应关系,因此可用于制定最佳药物剂量的实用指南。