Barr W
University of Liverpool, Health and Community Care Research Unit, Liverpool, England.
J Adv Nurs. 2000 May;31(5):1189-98. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2648.2000.01374.x.
Community mental health nurses have been criticized for failing to prioritize work with people with a severe or enduring mental illness, many of whom have no contact with specialist mental health services and rely entirely on their general practitioner and primary care team. It is important to ensure that those in contact with specialist services actually need this level of input but, conversely, that those in contact with only primary care receive a service that is equipped to meet their needs. This study examines the differences between these two groups of patients. A sample of 253 community-based patients with a severe or enduring mental illness was divided into those with mental health service contact and those without. Differences in the demographic characteristics of the two groups were assessed and further, more detailed, comparisons were made with a sub-sample of 49 individuals randomly drawn from this larger sample. Instruments adopted for these purposes comprised the Camberwell Assessment of Need and the Life Fulfilment Scale. It was found that patients with a psychotic disorder were more likely than those with neurosis to be in contact with mental health services and patients with schizophrenia were significantly more likely to be on the active caseload of a community mental health nurse than those from all other diagnostic groups. However, patients' levels of need, unmet need and quality of life did not differ in relation to their service contact. Whilst the study provides limited evidence that community mental health nurses are targeting people with the most serious disorders, questions remain about the large proportion not receiving specialist care. Because primary care plays a significant role in the care of severely mentally ill people living in the community, the further mental health training of general practitioners and practice nurses is becoming increasingly important.
社区精神卫生护士因未能将与重度或持续性精神疾病患者的工作置于优先地位而受到批评,其中许多患者未与专科精神卫生服务机构接触,完全依赖其全科医生和初级保健团队。重要的是要确保与专科服务机构接触的人确实需要这种程度的投入,但相反,仅与初级保健机构接触的人能获得满足其需求的服务。本研究考察了这两组患者之间的差异。将253名患有重度或持续性精神疾病的社区患者样本分为有精神卫生服务接触者和无精神卫生服务接触者。评估了两组人群的人口统计学特征差异,并进一步从这个较大样本中随机抽取49人的子样本进行了更详细的比较。为此采用的工具包括《坎伯韦尔需求评估》和《生活满意度量表》。研究发现,患有精神障碍的患者比患有神经症的患者更有可能与精神卫生服务机构接触,与所有其他诊断组的患者相比,精神分裂症患者显著更有可能在社区精神卫生护士的活跃病例清单上。然而,患者的需求水平、未满足的需求和生活质量与其服务接触情况无关。虽然该研究提供了有限的证据表明社区精神卫生护士针对的是患有最严重疾病的人群,但对于未接受专科护理的很大一部分人仍存在疑问。由于初级保健在社区中重度精神疾病患者的护理中发挥着重要作用,全科医生和执业护士的进一步精神卫生培训变得越来越重要。