Shelly A D, Southard T E, Southard K A, Casko J S, Jakobsen J R, Fridrich K L, Mergen J L
Department of Orthodontics, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2000 Jun;117(6):630-7.
Our purpose was to investigate the impact of mandibular advancement surgery on profile esthetics and to attempt to define guidelines that could be of value to the clinician in predicting profile esthetic change. The sample consisted of 34 patients who had been treated with a combination of orthodontics and mandibular advancement surgery without genioplasty. Initial (pretreatment) and final (posttreatment) cephalometric radiographs of each patient were used to produce silhouette images and to quantify skeletal changes that occurred with surgery. The images were displayed randomly to lay persons and orthodontic residents who were asked to score the esthetics of each profile. On average, after mandibular advancement surgery, B point moved forward 5.0 mm (SD = 2.6 mm) and downward 4.7 mm (SD = 3.1 mm), and the ANB angle decreased 3.0 degrees (SD = 1.6 degrees ) Graphical analysis and results of paired t tests revealed that for patients with an initial ANB angle >/= 6 degrees, a consistent improvement in profile esthetics was seen following surgery (P </=.001). This represented, on average, about a 45% improvement in esthetics. For patients with an initial ANB angle < 6 degrees, an improvement in profile esthetics after surgery was seen about half the time but poorer esthetics were equally likely. These results underscore the importance of using the ANB angle as a skeletal guideline when deciding whether to treat patients with mandibular advancement surgery. If improved profile esthetics are a desired outcome, an initial ANB angle of at least 6 degrees is recommended.
我们的目的是研究下颌前徙手术对侧貌美学的影响,并试图制定对临床医生预测侧貌美学变化有价值的指导原则。样本包括34例接受正畸和下颌前徙手术联合治疗且未行颏成形术的患者。利用每位患者的初始(治疗前)和最终(治疗后)头影测量X线片生成轮廓图像,并量化手术引起的骨骼变化。这些图像随机展示给普通人和正畸住院医师,要求他们对每个侧貌的美学进行评分。平均而言,下颌前徙手术后,B点向前移动5.0 mm(标准差=2.6 mm),向下移动4.7 mm(标准差=3.1 mm),ANB角减小3.0度(标准差=1.6度)。图形分析和配对t检验结果显示,对于初始ANB角≥6度的患者,术后侧貌美学有持续改善(P≤.001)。这平均代表美学改善约45%。对于初始ANB角<6度的患者,术后约一半时间侧貌美学有改善,但美学变差的可能性同样存在。这些结果强调了在决定是否用下颌前徙手术治疗患者时,将ANB角作为骨骼指导原则的重要性。如果期望获得改善的侧貌美学效果,建议初始ANB角至少为6度。