Jacobs R J, Grover S F, Meyerhoff A S, Paivana T A
Capitol Outcomes Research, Inc, Alexandria, Virginia 22310 , USA.
J Food Prot. 2000 Jun;63(6):768-74. doi: 10.4315/0362-028x-63.6.768.
Foodborne transmission is an important means of hepatitis A infection that may be reduced through vaccination of food service workers (FSWs). Several states are considering actions to encourage or mandate FSW vaccination, but the cost effectiveness of such policies has not been assessed. We estimated the clinical and economic consequences of vaccinating FSWs from the 10 states with the highest reported rates of hepatitis A. A decision analytic model was used to predict the effects of vaccinating FSWs at age 20 years. It was assumed all FSWs would receive one dose of inactivated hepatitis A vaccine, and 50% would receive the second recommended dose. Parameter estimates were obtained from published reports and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention databases. The primary endpoint was cost per year of life saved (YOLS). Secondary endpoints were symptomatic infections, days of illness, deaths, and costs of hepatitis A treatment, public health intervention, and work loss. Each endpoint was considered separately for FSWs and patrons. We estimate vaccination of 100,000 FSWs would cost $8.1 million but reduce the costs of hepatitis A treatment, public health intervention, and work loss by $3.0 million, $2.3 million, and $3.1 million, respectively. Vaccination would prevent approximately 2,500 symptomatic infections, 93,000 days of illness, and 8 deaths. A vaccination policy would reduce societal costs while costing the health system $13,969 per YOLS, a ratio that exceeds generally accepted standards of cost effectiveness.
食源性传播是甲型肝炎感染的一种重要途径,通过对食品服务工作者(FSW)进行疫苗接种可以减少这种传播。几个州正在考虑采取行动鼓励或强制FSW接种疫苗,但此类政策的成本效益尚未得到评估。我们估计了对甲型肝炎报告发病率最高的10个州的FSW进行疫苗接种的临床和经济后果。使用决策分析模型预测在20岁时对FSW进行疫苗接种的效果。假设所有FSW都将接种一剂甲型肝炎灭活疫苗,50%的人将接种第二剂推荐剂量的疫苗。参数估计值来自已发表的报告和疾病控制与预防中心的数据库。主要终点是每挽救一年生命的成本(YOLS)。次要终点是有症状感染、患病天数、死亡人数以及甲型肝炎治疗、公共卫生干预和工作损失的成本。分别针对FSW和顾客考虑每个终点。我们估计,对100,000名FSW进行疫苗接种将花费810万美元,但分别可减少甲型肝炎治疗、公共卫生干预和工作损失的成本300万美元、230万美元和310万美元。疫苗接种将预防约2500例有症状感染、93000天的患病时间以及8例死亡。疫苗接种政策将降低社会成本,同时卫生系统每YOLS花费13,969美元,这一比率超过了普遍接受的成本效益标准。