Spikman J M, Deelman B G, van Zomeren A H
Department of Clinical Psychology, Groningen State University, Groningen, Netherlands.
J Clin Exp Neuropsychol. 2000 Jun;22(3):325-38. doi: 10.1076/1380-3395(200006)22:3;1-V;FT325.
To study the presence and nature of dysexecutive problems after CHI, a series of unstructured tasks tapping executive functioning were selected. These were administered to a group of 51 participants with CHI in the chronic stage (i.e. several years post-injury) and to 45 healthy controls. In addition, well-known structured tests of attention and planning were administered. Of the executive tasks, only the Executive Route Finding task showed a significant difference between both groups. A multivariate analysis on the attention tests showed a significant difference between groups, indicating that patients in the chronic stage still process information slower than controls. Within the patient group, patients with and without frontal focal lesions were also compared on executive and attention tests. No differences were found with respect to the latter. However, patients with frontal lesions performed worse on a measure of the Executive Route Finding task. It is concluded that patients with CHI, especially when they have frontal damage, have to rely more heavily on externally provided cues, but this dysexecutive problem can only be demonstrated in tasks that resemble daily life tasks by providing very little structure.
为研究闭合性颅脑损伤(CHI)后执行功能障碍问题的存在情况及性质,选取了一系列用于评估执行功能的非结构化任务。这些任务被施用于一组51名处于慢性期(即受伤数年之后)的CHI患者以及45名健康对照者。此外,还进行了著名的注意力和计划结构化测试。在执行任务中,只有执行路线寻找任务在两组之间显示出显著差异。对注意力测试的多变量分析表明两组之间存在显著差异,这表明慢性期患者处理信息的速度仍比对照组慢。在患者组内部,还对有和没有额叶局灶性病变的患者进行了执行和注意力测试比较。在后者方面未发现差异。然而,有额叶病变的患者在执行路线寻找任务的一项指标上表现更差。得出的结论是,CHI患者,尤其是那些有额叶损伤的患者,不得不更严重地依赖外部提供的线索,但这种执行功能障碍问题只有在通过提供极少结构来模拟日常生活任务的情况下才能表现出来。