Weaver M, Spigner C, Pineda M, Rabun K G, Allen M D
The Department of Health Services, School of Public Health, University of Washington, Seattle, USA.
Clin Transplant. 2000 Aug;14(4 Pt 1):292-303. doi: 10.1034/j.1399-0012.2000.140404.x.
Increasing the diversity of the organ donor pool might improve the opportunities for people of color on organ transplant waiting lists to receive donated organs. We report on the results of a pilot classroom health education program to improve knowledge about organ donation and transplantation among a diverse student body at an urban high school.
The effectiveness of the educational program was evaluated with baseline and follow-up questionnaires which examined: 1) whether the program increased knowledge about organ donation; 2) whether the students' opinions about organ donation changed; and 3) whether the program was related to any changes in opinion.
On the follow-up questionnaire, correct answers on 15 factual questions increased by 18% for the treatment group, compared to 5% for the control group (p = 0.00). Regarding opinions, at baseline 92% of white students had positive opinions about donation, compared to 48% of the students of color (p = 0.00). In the follow-up survey, the increase in positive opinions among the students of color was significantly greater than among white students (p = 0.04). In this pilot study, however, changes in opinions occurred with equal frequency among students in the treatment and control groups. In regression analysis, both knowledge of the subject and discussing donation with one's family were significantly associated with positive opinions about donation.
Overall, this pilot study provided encouraging evidence that the classroom health education program affected knowledge about organ donation, and that opinions about organ donation are responsive to increases in knowledge.
增加器官捐赠者群体的多样性可能会改善有色人种在器官移植等待名单上获得捐赠器官的机会。我们报告了一项试点课堂健康教育项目的结果,该项目旨在提高一所城市高中不同学生群体对器官捐赠和移植的认识。
通过基线问卷和后续问卷对教育项目的有效性进行评估,问卷考察了:1)该项目是否增加了对器官捐赠的了解;2)学生对器官捐赠的看法是否发生了变化;3)该项目是否与看法的任何变化有关。
在后续问卷中,治疗组在15个事实性问题上的正确答案增加了18%,而对照组为5%(p = 0.00)。关于看法,在基线时,92%的白人学生对捐赠持积极看法,而有色人种学生中这一比例为48%(p = 0.00)。在后续调查中,有色人种学生中积极看法的增加显著大于白人学生(p = 0.04)。然而,在这项试点研究中,治疗组和对照组学生看法的变化频率相同。在回归分析中,对该主题的了解以及与家人讨论捐赠都与对捐赠的积极看法显著相关。
总体而言,这项试点研究提供了令人鼓舞的证据,表明课堂健康教育项目影响了对器官捐赠的了解,并且对器官捐赠的看法会随着知识的增加而改变。