Binetti P, Albano M G
Centro di Educazione Medica, Università Campus Bio-Medico, Roma, Italia.
Clin Ter. 2000 May-Jun;151(3):155-65.
To analyze the Best Evidence Medical Education approach (BEME) in relation to the need of improving the quality of education in medical faculties through strictly controlled forms of experiments.
Starting from the analysis of several Medical Education Centers in different Faculties of Medicine, their objectives, activities and quality control systems have been extrapolated in order to point out how institutions identify and control introduced changes. More in detail, a comparison between two italian Centers for Medical Education has been carried out: the one of Bari, which has been the first one in Italy, and the most recent one, at the Campus Bio-Medico, in Rome.
A tendency to apply the growing cultural acquisitions and the new criteria of economy and management to the medical field is developing, which asks for a particular attention to the quality control and to the cost-benefit analysis. Evidence based medicine tries therefore to validate the diagnostic and therapeutic decisions on the basis of experiments whose methodology belongs to the controlled clinical trials' model. These, despite some blind areas, are still a shared effort of the scientific community to objectify the analysis of a given problem and compare the results. Likewise, Evidence Based Medical Education is an attempt to maintain the need for experimenting effective educational forms without giving up their scientific validation. The Medical Education Centers in the different Faculties may have this research function which makes undergraduate medical education one of the three main aspects of the medical teacher's role: research, care and education.
通过严格控制的实验形式,分析最佳证据医学教育方法(BEME)与提高医学院校教育质量需求之间的关系。
从对不同医学院校的多个医学教育中心的分析入手,推断出它们的目标、活动和质量控制体系,以指出各机构如何识别和控制引入的变革。更详细地说,对意大利的两个医学教育中心进行了比较:一个是意大利首个医学教育中心——巴里的医学教育中心,另一个是罗马生物医学大学校园的最新医学教育中心。
将不断增长的文化成果以及新的经济与管理标准应用于医学领域的趋势正在发展,这就要求特别关注质量控制和成本效益分析。因此,循证医学试图基于属于对照临床试验模式的实验来验证诊断和治疗决策。尽管存在一些盲点,但这些仍然是科学界为使给定问题的分析客观化并比较结果而共同做出的努力。同样,循证医学教育是一种在不放弃科学验证的情况下,维持对有效教育形式进行实验的需求的尝试。不同医学院校的医学教育中心可能具有这种研究功能,这使得本科医学教育成为医学教师角色的三个主要方面之一:研究、护理和教育。