Stephen L J, Sills G J, Brodie M J
University Department of Medicine and Therapeutics, Western Infirmary, Glasgow, Scotland.
Epilepsia. 2000 Aug;41(8):977-80. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.2000.tb00282.x.
This prospective observational study explored the efficacy and tolerability of topiramate (TPM) in patients with refractory epilepsy attending a single outpatient clinic.
One hundred seventy patients (82 men, 88 women, aged 18-75 years) with refractory localization-related (n = 134) or idiopathic generalized epilepsy (n = 36) were started on adjunctive TPM using a standard titration schedule. TPM was introduced after a 3-month prospective baseline, and doses were adjusted according to clinical response. End points were seizure freedom for 6 months, > or =50% seizure reduction for 6 months compared with baseline at the highest tolerated TPM dose (responder), or discontinuation of TPM because of side effects, lack of efficacy, or both.
Thirty-nine (23%) patients were seizure-free, and 80 (47%) more patients had a useful therapeutic response. Thirteen seizure-free patients and 16 responders took 100 mg of TPM daily or less. TPM was discontinued in 51 (30%) patients. The most common side effects resulting in withdrawal were fatigue, weight loss, irritability, paresthesia, depression, and headache. Concomitant antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) were stopped in 30 patients. Twelve were established on TPM monotherapy, eight of whom remained seizure-free. Final TPM doses and concentrations varied widely among the three outcome groups.
TPM was efficacious as add-on and monotherapy in patients with refractory partial and generalized seizures in everyday clinical use. A good response was obtained in many patients with TPM doses substantially lower than those studied in regulatory clinical trials. The wide variation in dose-response and dose-toxicity relationships may reflect different neurobiologies causing refractory epilepsy and differential efficacy of AED combinations.
本前瞻性观察性研究探讨了托吡酯(TPM)对在单一门诊就诊的难治性癫痫患者的疗效和耐受性。
170例患者(82例男性,88例女性,年龄18 - 75岁)患有难治性局灶性相关性癫痫(n = 134)或特发性全身性癫痫(n = 36),采用标准滴定方案开始辅助使用TPM。在进行3个月的前瞻性基线观察后引入TPM,并根据临床反应调整剂量。终点指标为6个月无癫痫发作、在最高耐受TPM剂量下与基线相比癫痫发作减少≥50%达6个月(有反应者),或因副作用、缺乏疗效或两者兼而停止使用TPM。
39例(23%)患者无癫痫发作,另外80例(47%)患者有有效的治疗反应。13例无癫痫发作患者和16例有反应者每日服用100 mg或更少剂量的TPM。51例(30%)患者停用TPM。导致停药的最常见副作用为疲劳、体重减轻、易怒、感觉异常、抑郁和头痛。30例患者停用了联合使用的抗癫痫药物(AEDs)。12例患者确立了TPM单药治疗,其中8例仍无癫痫发作。最终TPM剂量和血药浓度在三个结局组之间差异很大。
在日常临床应用中,TPM作为难治性部分性和全身性癫痫患者的辅助治疗和单药治疗均有效。许多患者使用的TPM剂量显著低于监管临床试验中研究的剂量,但仍获得了良好反应。剂量反应和剂量毒性关系的广泛差异可能反映了导致难治性癫痫的不同神经生物学机制以及AED联合用药的不同疗效。